[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / adv / an / asp / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / out / po / pol / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / x] [rs] [@] [Settings] [Rules] [FAQ] [Feedback] [Status] [Home]
Board
SettingsHome
4chan
/mlp/ - Pony

Your ad here
[Advertise on 4chan]

Posting mode: Reply
Name
E-mail
Subject
Spoilers[]
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this CAPTCHA. [Learn More] [Login]
File
[]
Password (Password used for deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Japanese このサイトについて - 翻訳

You don't have to be a doctor to save lives.
Just donate blood.
It's safe. It's simple. And it saves lives.
[Advertise on 4chan]

File: 1383401014246.png-(917 KB, 2356x1668, 1353192018440.png)
917 KB
917 KB PNG
PINK THREAD

POST PINK

OR DIE

LAST NOT COMPLETELY PINK HORSE
>>14329695
>>
File: 1383401073425.gif-(391 KB, 595x444, Twerkaloo.gif)
391 KB
391 KB GIF
>>
Pony says it's much safer behind wall Sina.
>>
File: 1383401085202.png-(299 KB, 1348x1080, 303619__safe_rarity_wat_h(...).png)
299 KB
299 KB PNG
Oh boy! Pink threads are my favorite!
>>
File: 1383401099218.png-(91 KB, 657x567, WEH.png)
91 KB
91 KB PNG
>>14333897
IS THAT PINK ENOUGH FOR YOU
>>
but
i wanted to make the throd
>>
>>14333897
You are the anon that deletes threads huh?
>>
File: 1383401131596.png-(101 KB, 472x416, 1380892532420.png)
101 KB
101 KB PNG
Thanks pink.
>>
>>14333908
I'm a Rara teapot short and stout
>>
File: 1383401165828.png-(721 KB, 1000x1000, Celestia Watering Flower (...).png)
721 KB
721 KB PNG
>>14333897
YOU SHALL NEVER MAKE ME BETRAY LADY RARITY AND POST YOUR HORRIBLE PINK HELLSPAWN

But have pink horse anyway
>>
Why is the comic so terrible?
>>
So I got that tattoo of my waifu
>>
>>14333927
le reddit pandering
>>
>>14333927
Because you are weebo punk bitch
>>
>>14333927
because faggots keep telling you how great it is but it's merely adequate
>>
File: 1383401268857.gif-(963 KB, 300x253, 1352581034705.gif)
963 KB
963 KB GIF
>>
>>14333942
AAAAAAA
>>
>>14333942
OH GOD PHOTOSHOP WHAT DID YOU DO
>>
>>14333927
Because the comic has more forced references than the show itself.

Every fucking panel is a reference to remind you how funny pop-culture jokes are.
>>
>>14333946
Oh, that reminds me that we'll probably have a few jokes spoiled.
>>
>>14333946
>tfw we had that part ruined for us
>>
Guys, I don't think I'm edging right. I think I push myself a little too close and it all just sorta leaks out. I finally said fuck it and pushed myself over, but all it did was make it hurt some at the end. What am I doing wrong?
>>
How come I've never seen anyone complain about the pop-culture references in the show?
>>
>>14333958
I can answer that.

NOT YOUR FUCKING BLOG, YOU PIECE OF FUCKING SHIT. :^)
>>
>>14333958
Are you the dumbass that is taking all thise pills and drinking water just to pre?
>>
>>14333952
I didn't mind. I didn't get most of them and most were in the background. I can't think of a single pop culture joke that killed the plot or the action.
>>
>>14333954
We've been trailer proof for months now, unlike in S3 where we got tons of footage before the premier.

>>14333962
Because they aren't as forced or as common.
>>
>>14333958
You're supposed to have a pony's mouth wrapped over your cock so that there's no leaks
>>
>>14333962

because unlike the comic the show doesn't fill entire scenes and locations with wall to wall and varying references
>>
>>14333976
The S4 premiere will be ruined for us at least a week in advance.
>>
>>14333962
Because most of the episodes aren't forced pop-culture jokes like the Baby Cakes one.
>>
>>14333962
A lot less of them and a lot harder to spot.
>>
>>14333956
>tfw I hate spoilers but can never resist seeking them out
>>
>>14333976
>>14333989
What do you mean by "forced"?
>>
>>14333976
We got most of the S3 footage in the last 2 weeks.
>>
File: 1383401628721.gif-(403 KB, 295x370, 1383401141086.gif)
403 KB
403 KB GIF
Jees i had to re-save the gif.
Adobe wtf.
>>
>>14333923
Pony insists that the walls are the divine might of kamisama
>>
>>14333993
>tfw me too
>tfw but I don't really care anymore because I'm confident the first part of S4 will be awful and therefore might as well spoil it for myself at any given opportunity
>>
File: 1383401685717.png-(231 KB, 702x896, exhaustive testing.png)
231 KB
231 KB PNG
I expanded on the concept a little at the request of no one so

here's Twilight and Discord doing some research
>>
Remember when everyone was so excited when they revealed discord? And when MLPG used to be about fun? Yeah. Now its all gone to shit. S4 will be shit because it will pander to furries.
>>
>>14333993
>>14334007
Better being informed than end up being a tool who buys shit games.
>>
>>14333993
>tfw spoilers never ruined anything for me, only made me more curious and interested in the thing
>>
>>14333996
The scene doesn't provide a good environment for the reference could be one case, the other is when it just goes out of the way with making the reference itself and it sticks out way too much. For both of these a great example is the panel with Huey, Dewey and Louie.
>>
>>14334012
do you think we will finally get schoolgirl pones?!
>>
>>14334011
THE JOKE

IS

SEX
>>
>>14334028
it's sexhausting
>>
>>14334028
Is it suppose to be funny anymore?
>>
File: 1383401827801.png-(492 KB, 1251x735, filly trio.png)
492 KB
492 KB PNG
>>14334026

We already have schoolfillies anon
>>
>>14334011
le funnay sex joek
>>
Pony said that that as amazing and you should do it again
>>
>>14334011
Oh, that reminds me of that comic where Rarity grades a stallion and comments on his volume.
>>
>>14334011
Heh.

ow I want to read a fic on this.
>>
>>14334011
Are the pink lines her shuddering, or just magic?
>>
File: 1383401895704.png-(222 KB, 702x896, exhaustive testing.png)
222 KB
222 KB PNG
>>14334011
wow this is what I get for last-minute revisions

>>14334028
no anon, the subject is sex
>>
>>14334025
Is that really enough to make a comic bad?
>>
>>14334038
FS please, I am not a horse pedophile.
I meant pones in schoolgirl outfit
>>
>>14334054

When it is constantly done it can
>>
>>14334038
Why are fillies so cute
It's a danger to our nation's security.
>>
>>14334028
There really isn't a joke in that one.
>>
>>14334054
No, but it's enough to make a panel bad, and >>14334059 applies.
>>
>>14334028
>>14334039
>implying every comic has to be funny
>>
>>14334053
I thought it was more amusing, in a weird way, when it read "fuzzy texture increased in a variety of situations".
>>
>>14334059
How so? It's not something that detracts from the story since the writing isn't being effected and the art doesn't decrease in quality. I think you guys are confusing your own dislike of something with things that are actually bad in quality.
>>
File: 1383402048839.gif-(372 KB, 400x235, fillies are pleased.gif)
372 KB
372 KB GIF
>>14334058

>I am not a horse pedophile.

Well, I am glad to hear that anon.

>>14334062

I don't know anon but science needs to find an answer

Also I had meant to post the .gif version of that oops
>>
>>14334066
>my fetish is shit tier art

Why didn't you say so?
>>
PON PLANET PoN PLANET PON PLANET
>>
>>14334078
Here we go again
>>
>>14334054
For me not really. Most of the time they are done well and don't get in the way. The ducktales one is one of the worse ones but still 99% of them are just in the background and out of the center of attention.

It's not a real reason to say the comics are bad but it is a flaw and some people might find it very annoying.
>>
>>14334090
>we
>>
>>14334078

It detracts from the very integrity of the setting by dragging completely unrelated intellectual property into a place it has no business being. That is a definite decrease in quality, just not in the visual sense.
>>
File: 1383402264804.png-(26 KB, 789x317, flutterbutter.png)
26 KB
26 KB PNG
>>14334103
>It detracts from the very integrity of the setting
>>
>>14334103
That doesn't really make a whole lot of sense since the references are usually in the background and never mentioned again.
>>
I don't think the comic really has any of the qualities that made the show good originally. Just my opinion. I'm not trying to bash it.
>>
>>14334109
Go back to drawing fetish shit instead of trying to join in a discussion.
>>
>>14334062
Cute and/or sexual fillies are the glue that holds our nation's infrastructure in one piece. Take those out of the equation and everything collapses.
>>
>>14334124
I agree with that. Perhaps it's too mature.
>>
File: 1383402433009.png-(164 KB, 702x896, noteworthy.png)
164 KB
164 KB PNG
>>14334053
>>
>>14334053
>>14334011
Body size difference
unf
>>
>>14334124
You mean the comic doesn't have cute ponies being cute while doing silly things?
>>
File: 1383402498612.jpg-(60 KB, 212x237, a background stallion pon(...).jpg)
60 KB
60 KB JPG
>>14334140

Well, it has some hideous ones at least
>>
>>14334124
The Big mac comic is the only one really.
>>
File: 1383402530494.png-(24 KB, 800x600, lazymoon.png)
24 KB
24 KB PNG
>>14334129
how about you make me nerd
>>
>>14334109
What's wrong fluttershy?
>>
File: 1383402582680.gif-(41 KB, 227x227, 1380909952198.gif)
41 KB
41 KB GIF
>>14334136
>>
>>14334151

GG pls draw lewd Gillou
>>
File: 1383402631571.jpg-(184 KB, 971x1500, 345528__solo_suggestive_s(...).jpg)
184 KB
184 KB JPG
>>14334134
Silly anon.
Fillies are not for sexual.
>>
File: 1383402671651.png-(143 KB, 270x272, carrot and toothpaste pon(...).png)
143 KB
143 KB PNG
>>14334147

Yeah, the big mac one is the only one that seems to have the same feel for me as well. The ones with Chrysalis had their moments though
>>
Sinfest was a pretty good comic for a while.
>>
File: 1383402702803.gif-(834 KB, 245x200, What the fuck did you jus(...).gif)
834 KB
834 KB GIF
>>14334136
>>
File: 1383402720102.gif-(72 KB, 150x112, 1374694258038.gif)
72 KB
72 KB GIF
>>14334163
>Fillies are not for sexual
>>
File: 1383402774074.png-(358 KB, 962x618, 1372310076239.png)
358 KB
358 KB PNG
>>14334176
Well fine, okay, they can be for sexual.
But only with other fillies and colts.
>>
File: 1383402782538.jpg-(15 KB, 234x215, iktfb.jpg)
15 KB
15 KB JPG
>>14334172
Fuck, Anon, don't remind me.
>tfw you used to read it daily
>tfw you waited eagerly for the big color page on sundays
>>
>>14334172
No it wasn't. Even when it wasn't going down the road it's going down now it was still really mediocre.

Christ, you people have the worst taste in comic.
>>
>>14334109
From an immersion stand point he's kind of right. Do you really expect people to buy into the fact that there's a pony counterpart to EVERY SINGLE POP CULTURE THING IN THE WORLD in Equestria?
>>
File: 1383402896702.gif-(1.7 MB, 210x155, 1366365384295.gif)
1.7 MB
1.7 MB GIF
>Typing "Art progress" on deviantart
>Looking at AGDG and seeing developers become better over time
I want to die
>>
>>14334198

>immersion
>My Little Pony
>>
>>14334198
They are visual gags not meant to be taken seriously. You're not supposed to stop and ponder "Does [this character] really live in Equestria"

It's like you people never read comics before.
>>
Rarity is not a slut
>>
File: 1383402995992.gif-(2.22 MB, 290x595, 1370091521235.gif)
2.22 MB
2.22 MB GIF
>>14334213
>>
File: 1383403005054.png-(1.95 MB, 4648x5000, the stare.png)
1.95 MB
1.95 MB PNG
>>14334213
>>
>>14334208
>You're not supposed to stop and ponder "Does [this character] really live in Equestria"
You've supported a great counter-point there. The shittier references in the comics do exactly that with you, when they go out of their way to make sure everyone gets the reference and it looks weird as fuck and not fitting.
>Are there really duck ponies in Equestria?
>>
File: 1383403029231.png-(277 KB, 1056x756, RumbleTiara.png)
277 KB
277 KB PNG
>>14334183
This
>>
>>14334208
But it does make you ponder if you see fucking character references on every fucking panel.
>>
File: 1383403070360.png-(4 KB, 189x189, mfw.png)
4 KB
4 KB PNG
>>14334198
>From an immersion stand point
it's a visual gag
do you really expect people to stop and go WAIT A MINUTE PONIES THAT LIVE IN PONYVILLE AND JUST HAPPEN TO LOOK LIKE THE BLUES BROTHERS? HIGHLY DUBIOUS
>>
>>14334208
Are they really visual gags if they're so many of them at this point? Fuck, it's easier to look for panels and pages without references everywhere.
>>
Mayor Mare.
>>
File: 1383403107538.png-(280 KB, 1304x933, 1372087076195.png)
280 KB
280 KB PNG
>>14334226
Colts with fillies is just the cutest thing
>>
I love that bonus part where Luna isn't banished and the SA/Cadence comic was just a big rickroll.
>>
File: 1383403144203.gif-(506 KB, 240x313, mayor.gif)
506 KB
506 KB GIF
>>14334238
She's a pretty damn good mare.
>>
>>14334224
>The shittier references in the comics do exactly that with you,

They may do that with you, but they don't do that for everyone. Not everyone over thinks things like this. You see a little reference in the background that's never going to be mentioned again as the comic progresses that's it.

>>14334236
Yes. The abundance of the does not change this.
>>
File: 1383403252550.gif-(382 KB, 573x500, #notnightthread.gif)
382 KB
382 KB GIF
>>
>>14334236
>Are they really visual gags if they're so many of them at this point?
yes
>>
>>14334235

>You see a little reference in the background that's never going to be mentioned again

but that is not true. There are several gag lines that keep getting reused constantly. Sailor Moon and Star Trek being two I can think of immediately
>>
File: 1383403338446.png-(69 KB, 578x671, 1368269283041.png)
69 KB
69 KB PNG
>>14334261

gg pls
>>
>>14334239
>you will never be the little colt
>>
>>14334267
>this guy is trying to talk about ponies
>better bother him with unrelated bullshit
>>
>>14334264

oops meant that for >>14334250
>>
>Glitter Shit supporting the comic

Maybe they will hire him as an artist for drawing one of their comics?

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
File: 1383403437920.jpg-(23 KB, 253x330, Screenshot_6.jpg)
23 KB
23 KB JPG
>>14334238
is a hottie
>>
>>14334279
anon that was uncalled for
>>
>>14334270
;_;
>>
MLPG why do you hate MLP so much
>>
>>14334264
>gag lines

You mean background references
>>
>>14334286
I guess he's what we'd call an anonymous meanie
>>
>>14334270
I'd rather be the little filly for the little colt.

>Tfw i'll never be the little filly for you as the little colt
>>
what if foodscat
>>
>>14334279
He has way more of a chance then you do.
>>
>>14334257
>those eyebrows
>>
>>14334291
But I like MLP
>>
File: 1383403631615.jpg-(443 KB, 1125x1125, 1382873547063.jpg)
443 KB
443 KB JPG
>>14334299
yes, what about them?
>>
>>14334291

Have you ever been to /vg/?

All generals hate the things they're associated with.
>>
File: 1383403685703.png-(243 KB, 1400x1572, MLP - Luna1.png)
243 KB
243 KB PNG
Luna Quest today
>>
>>14334298
But Cocksucker!

ANYONE has more chances than him to draw the comic! :^)
>>
>>14334297
What if you jammed your fork into an electrical outlet?
>>
>>14334292

No, I mean gag line.

A background reference for the sake of humor in the context of a visual medium is a visual gag. A line refers to continuing occurrence of that gag.

The two I listed are the most obvious examples but I think we could technically count harry potter now as well
>>
>>14334320
But I only have forks with wooden, water-treated handles, Anon.
>>
>>14334318
Aw yis.
>>
>>14334319
I don't even want to draw for the comic
why is this suddenly a line of attack anon
>>
>>14334324
And so far all these things have been kept to the background not effecting the art or the plot of the comics they were featured in.
>>
>>14334335
yeah, that's the joke

no one wants you to draw an offical comic :^)
>>
>>14334291
I don't hate MLP, I love it. If I don't love it, then I don't... watch it. I still watch it.
>>
>>14334345
>kept to the background

The Ducktale ponies definitely weren't.
>>
>>14334346
>no one wants you to draw an offical comic :^)
right, I agree
>>
>>14334318
>collaborative fanfiction circlejerking

pls no
>>
>>14334329
Fag.
>>
>>14334345

Well that's good because nobody has complained about the art quality or the comic writing
>>
>>14334355
And that's one instance (two if you want to count the Mabel pony in the Nightmare Rarity arc) and both are never mentioned again and neither had any effect on the plot or art of said comics.
>>
>>14334346
>le [s4s] :^) face

Don't you have a sticky in there to shitpost in?
>>
>>14334369
When you're talking about a comic book those should be the only things that matter.
>>
What if time itself is dying
And it's taking us all with it!?
>>
The rational wiki is PISSED OFF at Pinkie Pie
"Feeling Pinkie Keen"
The fifteenth episode of the first season, "Feeling Pinkie Keen," is filled with woo. In the episode, Twilight learns that her friend Pinkie Pie appears to possess precognitive powers. Twilight spends the duration of the episode trying to find a rational, scientific explanation for Pinkie's abilities. At the end of the episode, after a particularly dangerous adventure spurred by Pinkie's precognition, Twilight gives up on trying to find an explanation and says that some things in the universe don't have any rational explanation. During the closing scene, she explains that "I now realize there are wonderful things in this world you just can't explain, but that doesn't necessary make them any less true. It just means you have to choose to believe in them. And sometimes, it takes a friend to show you the way."
The episode prompted significant criticism from the teenage/adult male fanbase, many of whom are atheists and believed the episode's questionable moral was an indictment of critical thinking and scientific skepticism. The implication that Twilight is a bad friend because she does not believe the same (unproven) things as her friends has been accused of being a promotion of the bandwagon argument, a particularly dangerous moral to impose on children. Lauren Faust, the show's creator, denied that the episode was supposed to promote religious faith or criticise skepticism, and expressed disappointment that the episode was interpreted as such, stating; "if I could have anticipated such a misunderstanding, I would have revised [the episode]."
>>
>>14334385
Nuffy pls stop
>>
>>14334388
>implying this wasn't the episode that ruined everything science-related with Twilight
>>
Can you get banned for announcing that you are NOT reporting a thread, even if it is in violation of the rules?

Can you get banned for announcing that you are going to "noko" a thread?
>>
>>14334388
What is your reply to their RAGE my friends...
>>
>>14334386
But overloading a comic with references can in fact affect the comic. For example, in the Megaman comic they got so bad that the editor told the writer to knock that shit out.
>>
>>14334388
Atheists: 1
Christians: 0
>>
Pone's such a bitch when she's in heat
>>
File: 1383404393730.png-(223 KB, 800x800, 1383351294051.png)
223 KB
223 KB PNG
>>
>>14334407
>references to the fucking megaman games

U FUCKING WOT M8
>>
File: 1383404421057.png-(426 KB, 994x698, bonbon and cherry being grumpy.png)
426 KB
426 KB PNG
>>14334411

Just avoid her for a few days anon

Though if that makes ponies bitchy there must be some that have very frequent cycles
>>
>>14334407
It could be worse: it could have been nothing but fandom references shoehorned in in the most painful way possible.
>>
>>14334423
Like tony fleece?
>>
>>14334403
well, Twilight did spend the whole day measuring her accuracy... and Pinkie did indeed have a better-than-chance prediction rate.
>>
>>14334423
Did you just predict future S4 episodes that are written by newcomer writers?
>>
>>14334407
Affect it in what way? I could understand if every other line a character said was a reference to pop-culture, I'd agree with you if that was the case.

And the thing about the Megaman AND Sonic comics is that that is exactly what Ian does. Every chance he gets he'll have Sonic reference something from another piece of sonic related material, but use it in the worst possible way.
>>
File: 1383404638254.jpg-(34 KB, 276x255, 1383268358196.jpg)
34 KB
34 KB JPG
>>14334437
But Ian is the one who saved the Sonic comics for being fucking shit.

And his boner for Eggman.
>>
File: 1383404640268.gif-(978 KB, 245x234, HDFFpyr.gif)
978 KB
978 KB GIF
>>14334435
>>
File: 1383404718615.png-(136 KB, 400x298, 1376363086236.png)
136 KB
136 KB PNG
>we will get more shit writers than good writers
>>
>>14334437
Eggman used his A rank quote from SA2 when he destroyed a GUN outpost and got away in a stolen jet.

I'd say that fits. Though "Sky patrol" for whatever Tails and Rotor were doing isn't.
>>
>>14334318
That's in 3 hours, isn't it?
>>
>Caring about writing
I just want to see more ponies, I don't care about writing
>>
Guys guys! Listen, a minute ago I was in an incredibly happy mood! I even wanted to talk about pons and talk about silly situations they would be in! For a moment I was euphoric. For a moment I was a brony. It... It felt good anon. Really good.
>>
>>14334448
>But Ian is the one who saved the Sonic comics for being fucking shit.

That's not what I'm arguing, though. Don't get me wrong, I like Ian and some of the things he's done to the comic, but he's really not as great of a writer that a lot of people claim he is.
>>
>>14334483
>I just want to eat more shit that look like pones

:^
>>
>>14334483
Then why are you watching the show?
>>
File: 1383404954387.png-(30 KB, 164x158, ponyhat.png)
30 KB
30 KB PNG
>>14334485
>>
>>14334496
I watch it for the plots.
>>
>>14334504
It's backstory, faggot.

Plot is for tits.
>>
File: 1383405106750.png-(17 KB, 828x769, i made a graph.png)
17 KB
17 KB PNG
>>
File: 1383405140535.png-(1.13 MB, 4427x5000, 1375396003861.png)
1.13 MB
1.13 MB PNG
>>14334502
>>
>>14334520
I like it, but purple was higher in the first season
>>
They should make use of "Kid's Show Invincibility" more often, I think Celestia's pet phoenix was the only character that pulled a death fake out.
>>
>>14334520
th-they can be creative with alicorn twilight, r-right?
>>
>>14334520
Anon, Twilight got giant dip in Lesson Zero when the author for Twilight to be a crazy bitch just to make the kids laugh.
>>
>>14334492
So I absolutely have to enjoy the show for it's writing?
>>
The way I see it, writers (or artist in this case) compensate for their inability to come up with original concepts by overusing pop culture references.
>>
>>14334541
Well yeah
I mean that's one of its main selling points in the first 2 seasons, at least.
>>
>>14334541
Yes. It's the only thing saving it for being fucking shit and making you look like a brony who eats up everything.
>>
>>14334502
This is not a laughing matter .
>>
File: 1383405326248.png-(607 KB, 934x714, this pleases marketing pr(...).png)
607 KB
607 KB PNG
>>14334533

You mean Princess Twilight™
>>
>>14334541
No, the writing was never outstanding anyways
>>
>>14334541
No, but it should play a part in your enjoyment of the show.
>>
>>14334545
Doesn't Corey also overuse pop-culture references?
>>
>>14334551
>not PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE™®©
>>
>>14334552
The writing is or rather was always just competent enough to not be just another show for little girls. I always laugh when people say otherwise,
>>
File: 1383405431058.gif-(76 KB, 256x192, phoenix-coffee(b).gif)
76 KB
76 KB GIF
>>14334548
>>14334547
>>14334552
>>14334555

There is no single reason someone must like the show, everyone is entitled to have their own opinion. Wether they watch the show for cute ponies or the writing does not matter
>>
>>14334563
Your mom uses pop culture refrences.
>>
>>14334548
I don't really care about being called a brony simply for enjoying the show in a way that isn't purely enjoyed here.
>>14334555
It doesn't.

I never cared for story or writing in anything really, it's one of the reasons why I don't read books, stories are boring.
>>
File: 1383405460365.png-(Spoiler Image, 16 KB, 733x358)
Spoiler Image, 16 KB
16 KB PNG
>>14334551
If her wings got burned off, would she lose the title of princess forever?
>>
>>14334571
Just because it wasn't absolute shit doesn't mean it's good
>>
>>14334573
But the former makes you a fucking brony.
>>
>>14334563
Not really? Nothing comes to mind from her episodes.
>>
>>14334563
name a single pop culture reference in her episodes
>>
File: 1383405517130.png-(133 KB, 270x313, 1383279344867.png)
133 KB
133 KB PNG
>>14334580
Isn't that what I just said?
>>
>>14334576
>I don't really care about being called a brony

Then wear your fedora and get out.
>>
>>14334576
You will never a great artist anon. Reading is essential for a healthy life.
>>
File: 1383405544384.png-(506 KB, 1019x665, the twilys.png)
506 KB
506 KB PNG
>>14334579

They would have to call her Prince Twilight much to the confusing of everyone
>>
>>14334545
People usually make them to have fun, not only for themselves, but other people their age that read or watch what they've made
>>
>>14334588
Wasn't there an homage to Kill Bill in JFS?
>>
File: 1383405567923.gif-(59 KB, 256x192, phoenix-pointing(b).gif)
59 KB
59 KB GIF
>>14334583
You have no proof of that
You just cant tstand the thought of somone having a different opinion than you
>>
>>14334590
No, you said pony is a slut
>>
File: 1383405604011.png-(166 KB, 800x600, 1382451563510.png)
166 KB
166 KB PNG
Pony cant drink from cans please stop giving them to her. She just knocks them over.
>>
File: 1383405612762.png-(159 KB, 812x985, ponk be all like _______ (...).png)
159 KB
159 KB PNG
>>14334576
>I don't read books
>>
>>14334600
u w0t?
>>
>>14334600
THAT WAS THE FUCKING TRAIN EPISODE, M8

And it wasn't written by Corey.
>>
File: 1383405731994.png-(41 KB, 828x769, i made it better.png)
41 KB
41 KB PNG
>>
>>14334618
Your mom was a train. Giggity.
>>
>>14334626
But that wasn't my mom. That was you sucking my cock. :^)
>>
>>14334520
>>14334624

>image is 17KB
>add Ponk
>image is 41KB

holy shit that bitch is obese
>>
>>14334591
No, you greasy hiveminded neckbeard.
>>
>>14334573
>>14334576
If the writing is total shit, cute ponies can't save it. It's not a matter of opinions, if literally the only thing they'd show in an episode was Twilight losing her new pink dress and them going around town asking ponies if they'd seen it and then just finding it after 15 minutes pass and then having a tea party while talking about boyfriends, you wouldn't be watching it.
And before you think "oh, that actually sounds pretty good", no, there would be absolutely no jokes, no interesting little pieces of information, they'd show more of ponyville but it'd be all copy-pasted over from house to house, no new ponies would be introduced and none of the ponies would have a distinct personality including the main 6. That's bad writing. If you'd still watch that, and the rest of the show while assuming the rest of the episodes were of equal quality, then you have the right to say that you don't care about writing at all.
>>
I'm surprised no one mentioned the scary door from the chrysalis comic. that shit was way too distracting.
>>
>>14334636
That's pretty ironic, brony.

No seriously, wear your trenchcoat and fedora. And get the fuck out.
>>
>>14334643
That's actually one of the biggest examples of >>14334545
>>
>>14334639
>if literally the only thing they'd show in an episode was Twilight losing her new pink dress and them going around town asking ponies if they'd seen it and then just finding it after 15 minutes pass and then having a tea party while talking about boyfriends, you wouldn't be watching it.
Yes I would.
>>14334644
Only a fedorable sperg would honestly give two shits about story in a show for little girls, I'm a reasonable weird person who likes watching all kinds of show regardless of writing quality.
>>
Cargo shorts are pragmatic and comfortable.
>>
File: 1383406094701.jpg-(43 KB, 640x480, pinkie no! think of your (...).jpg)
43 KB
43 KB JPG
>>14334634
>>
>>14334520
Anon I'm afraid I disagree with your graph.
Sorry.
It\s till a very nice looking graph.
>>
>>14334662
I agree.
>>
File: 1383406177324.png-(27 KB, 500x125, euphoric.png)
27 KB
27 KB PNG
>>14334662
And fedoras are classy and stylish
>>
>>14334667
>RD has become much better since her MMDW nadir
>TS has become worse

>disagreeing with facts
>>
>>14334660
>fedorable sperg
>watches a cartoon for little girls

So, you are a fedora-wearing, neckbearded pedophile?

Good to know. :^)
>>
>>14334660
>Only a fedorable sperg would honestly give two shits about story in a show for little girls,
The writers would. I think it's pretty clear that they're trying to make a well-designed fantasy world and tell good stories in it. Mostly casual and lighthearted stories, but still.
>>
>>14334680
I only disagree with the Twilight part.
The dash part is spot on.
>>
>>14334660
Get the fuck out, pedophile.
>>
>>14334680
You can't really know if Twilight has become worse after MMC because MMC was the last episode that aired.

Unless you have a crystal ball.
If you do, please tell me when my waifu will finally come for me ;__;
>>
>>14334682
>>14334683
>>14334693
yall niggaz is getting trol'd
>>
>>14334695
>If you do, please tell me when my waifu will finally come for me ;__;
She will come for your soul seven days after you die.
>>
File: 1383406369954.png-(138 KB, 312x337, Dinky 60.png)
138 KB
138 KB PNG
>>
File: 1383406378641.gif-(185 KB, 500x500, NO PANK.gif)
185 KB
185 KB GIF
>>
>>14334703
Natural death or any kind of death?
>>
I want a Windows 8 pony to be drawn.
And her smaller sister 8.1 being more popular.
>>
>>14334607
Don't worry ponka, I'll tip the can for you so you can drink out of it
>>
>>14334707
dinky pls
pls have an actual personality on the show
>>
>>14334693
>>14334682
Yeah, okay I'm a pedo
You found me out! I'm a pedo because I don't give two shits about story.
>>14334683
> well-designed fantasy world and tell good stories in it.
Well why did they decide to write for a show called my little pony friendship is magic?
>>14334699
>He doesn't have the same views as everyone!
>HE MUST BE A TROLL!
>>
>>14334607
just use a straw you silly bitch
>>
>>14334631
But anon, you had a micro cock. I luaghed so hard when I saw it I rolled all the way home.
>>
File: 1383406487682.png-(283 KB, 990x1200, Dinky 53.png)
283 KB
283 KB PNG
>>14334717
What kind of personality should dinky have?
>>
I watch MLP and I'm not a furry, pedophile, fedora wearer or brony sheep.
>>
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZacPOD-zCE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZacPOD-zCE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZacPOD-zCE
>>
File: 1383406553041.png-(167 KB, 600x600, 1379665924665.png)
167 KB
167 KB PNG
>>14334727
I watch MLP and i'm a furry pedophile, but not a fedora wearer or brony sheep.
>>
>>14334726
knowing mlpg, she'll probably be a slut in some way
>>
>>14334731
ITS SHIT
>>
>>14334731
There's nothing to complain about here beyond Twilight being a great flyer still.
Apparently they weren't bowing to her either in the group shot.
>>
>>14334731
>Popcorn
Discord i am disappoint.
Popcorn a shit.
>>
>>14334724
>needing ten years to respond
Seems like my cock wasn't that micro when you couldn't come up with a response in that time. :^)
>>
>>14334731
OH BOY HERE WE GO
>>
>>14334731
Dropped
>>
File: 1383406648181.png-(155 KB, 570x307, SYMBOLISM.png)
155 KB
155 KB PNG
>>14334731
haha anon, thats n-
>it's actually a season 04 promo
OH FUCK
>>
File: 1383406670502.png-(347 KB, 638x353, >bowing.png)
347 KB
347 KB PNG
>>14334731
So Meghan didn't lie.

Your move, bronies.
>>
File: 1383406675277.png-(104 KB, 466x290, popcorn.png)
104 KB
104 KB PNG
>>14334731
yay discord is in it
>>
File: 1383406682358.jpg-(5 KB, 167x200, 1351253010330.jpg)
5 KB
5 KB JPG
>>14334731
>Discord
>>
>>14334719
>Well why did they decide to write for a show called my little pony friendship is magic?
Some of them were fans of it as children. Others might have just been happy to get work. They might have seen it as a challenge. If I were a writer, I'd be happy about a chance to write for, say, Care Bears, and see if I could make a compelling narrative out of it.
>>
>>14334731
>It's night and day in every scene that shows the sky
>>
>>14334731

>Theyd didnt forget about Discord

SHOW REDEEMED
>>
>>14334731
Dat lighting
AW YISSSS
>>
File: 1383406735010.png-(342 KB, 568x310, libaryelements.png)
342 KB
342 KB PNG
>elements appearing again
>>
>>14334767
It's kind of weird because that's not how atmosphere works at all
>>
>>14334731
Well there's nothing really to be said about that.
Also why is Flutershy screaming. Retarded bitch wanted to live near the Everfree forest now she has to face the consequences.
>>
>>14334759
didn't lie about what

>DAT ZECORA
YAY SHE'S FINALLY IN THE INTRO
>>
>>14334731
>Twilight abusing her bullshit alicorn magic

It begins
>>
File: 1383406804749.png-(223 KB, 571x309, raymanorigins.png)
223 KB
223 KB PNG
those vines look like the rayman origins thorns
>>
>>14334709
Why? Are you thinking of quitting early?

But if you do that, you won't be able to share as many stories of the human world with her as she hoped. You don't want to disappoint her, do you?

>captcha: and rpsoni
You don't want to disappoint her and rpsoni, do you?
>>
File: 1383406827411.jpg-(214 KB, 1663x931, purplesmug.jpg)
214 KB
214 KB JPG
>>
>>14334771
John Delancie is probably only commanding $20 an hour these days, might as well keep using him.

Did you know he was in Breaking Bad for a few episodes?inb4 BrBa references in MLP
>>
>>14334731
DAT SKY LOOKS RAD AS FUCK
>>
>>14334789
>You don't want to disappoint her, do you?
I... I guess I don't
>>
File: 1383406873652.png-(49 KB, 200x231, dinky1.png)
49 KB
49 KB PNG
>>14334717
>>14334726

Well she is cute at least

I wonder what her voice would sound like
>>
HOLY SHIT DASH DID YOU LET YOURSELF GO
>>
File: 1383406874311.png-(305 KB, 567x307, raymanorigins2.png)
305 KB
305 KB PNG
>>14334786
no seriously they even move the same
>>
>>14334767
>It's always day and night at the same time
>We need a new name for this state, since day and night no longer cut it
Combination of NIGHt and dAY?
WE'LL CALL IT NEIGH
>>
>>14334780
It's a magical world.

It works like that because Twilight.

Do you even half day half night.
>>
>>14334754
My life doesn't revolve around mlpg. ;)
>>
>>14334731
>PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE™®© getting her own stainglass window in the palace
>none of her friends are in it

I'm getting really fucking tired of your bullshit, McCarthy
>>
File: 1383406911718.png-(298 KB, 625x627, FATASS.png)
298 KB
298 KB PNG
>>14334803
And as usual I forgot the image.
>>
File: 1383406917160.png-(177 KB, 1280x1280, 1369040783943.png)
177 KB
177 KB PNG
>>14334809
No
We call it Twilight
>>
I want this fedora meme to go away.

Every time the internet latches on to some new meme/joke they manage to run in to the ground within 3 fucking days and then continue to use it.
I'm sick of this whole mentality that consist of "it's going to be funny every time I use it" or "It's gets funnier each time"
>>
File: 1383406944696.png-(387 KB, 571x308, canterlotcrowd.png)
387 KB
387 KB PNG
background ponies
>>
>>14334782
She said they were getting ready for a group photo.
Everyone kept saying they were bowing to Twilight.
>>
>>14334795
I liked how they handled his character attempting suicide.
>>
>>14334818
Fedora meme has nothing to do with humor and everything to do with the stereotypes surrounding people who wear them.
>>
>>14334820
Truly the most interesting part of the show.
>>
>>14334821
Because the first half of the animation looks exactly like that. And then they suddenly stand up for a group photo.
>>
File: 1383407011684.png-(224 KB, 573x309, ASSUMINGDIRECTCONTROL.png)
224 KB
224 KB PNG
>>
File: 1383407014921.png-(625 KB, 945x761, 1364055978319.png)
625 KB
625 KB PNG
Theres only one solution.

We kill Twilight.
>>
>>14334820
Is the one on the left new?
>>
File: 1383407031816.png-(628 KB, 941x716, adorable snob ponies3.png)
628 KB
628 KB PNG
>>14334820

return of the adorable overdressed snob ponies
>>
>>14334818
On the other hand, it's a great way to determine if the other person is even worth having a discussion with.

As soon as he brings a fedora line you can just stop talking to them because it doesn't matter hwat you say anyway. Saves a lot of time.
>>
>>14334801
Then live your life to the fullest. Seek strength, seek willpower, seek happiness. Make your soul shine brightly for her.

It will be a delicious beginning.
>>
>>14334814
They have 2 stain glass windows, and even spike got one. They're not that important apparently.
>>
>>14334813
Then why bother responding?

REKT
>>
File: 1383407070225.png-(139 KB, 778x550, soaking wet mare.png)
139 KB
139 KB PNG
>>14334815
>filename
She has a big butt but calling her a "fatass" is kinda rude though
>>
>>14334834
Sweet & Elite was a great episode.
>>
>>14334818
I did not laugh per-say, however I did emit a sort of sharp sudden single breath through my nose and a small almost un-noticeable grin crept onto my slightly amused face. I don't applaud you, but I give you a confirmatory nod of the noggin.
>>
>>14334814
>>14334839
They just have to wait their turns for when they become alicorn princesses.
>>
File: 1383407109276.png-(273 KB, 569x308, incominganal.png)
273 KB
273 KB PNG
>>
>>14334842
You should draw Dash with some tight sweat pants that have "Juicy" bedazzled on the back.
>>
>>14334818
It's a fucking stereotype of neckbeards, faggot.
>>
File: 1383407130982.png-(2.53 MB, 3600x3600, Rebno Fat.png)
2.53 MB
2.53 MB PNG
>>14334842
Gotta go fats
>>
>>14334842
Nigga I'm just saying what I'm seeing.
She's fat. Hell |I bet the main reason she isn't in the Wonderbolts is because no one does Jumbo Jets suits.
>>
>>14334818
Shut the fuck up, we ponies now
>>
>>14334843
I agree, it's on par with The Cutie Pox and The Mysterious Mare Do Well. The song could have been in Equestria Girls, it was that good!
>>
>>14334786
>Land of the Livid Dead time attack

Never again.
>>
File: 1383407178868.png-(331 KB, 573x308, groupphoto.png)
331 KB
331 KB PNG
NOT BOWING CONFIRMED
>>
File: 1383407193289.png-(140 KB, 416x348, 1318691063989.png)
140 KB
140 KB PNG
>>14334842
fat
>>
>>14334731
It felt like I am watching a Discord episode again.
>>
File: 1383407207649.jpg-(269 KB, 499x718, rob the balloon guy.jpg)
269 KB
269 KB JPG
>>14334850
But I can't unf at my own art
>>
File: 1383407211416.gif-(12 KB, 256x192, phoenix-coffeed(a).gif)
12 KB
12 KB GIF
>>14334859
>>
File: 1383407231357.gif-(1.15 MB, 368x208, 2.gif)
1.15 MB
1.15 MB GIF
>>14334731
It feels weird to watch these previews after a long time without the actual show airing

Is this what hype feels like?
>>
File: 1383407247031.jpg-(93 KB, 1280x755, 1327790108472.jpg)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>>14334862
>>
File: 1383407257602.png-(188 KB, 570x309, 2SPOOKY.png)
188 KB
188 KB PNG
shipping confirmed also
>>
>>14334869
Then draw Dash, Celestia and Luna comparing their wings to determine who has the prettiest
>>
>>14334825
>>14334851
I get this, but it's not funny. People only seem to use it when they're trying to be funny. It's not funny. It's not even clever. Okay, maybe it was funny for a little bit, but when you have the internet spamming it and making unfunny variations of it it just becomes another stupid as hell meme that retards are going to latch on to until the next new meme/cool kid insult rolls around.
>>
>>14334862
Is that book Spike's holding the EoH book, Starswirl's book, or something else?
>>
>>14334872
Not really.

All I feel is just emptiness.
>>
>>14334872
Dooks, I can't believe you lost faith.
>>
>>14334859
>Rarifags buttmad that their slutwaifu was a complete bitch in an episode
>>
File: 1383407329234.png-(209 KB, 569x304, dispopcorn.png)
209 KB
209 KB PNG
also discord
>>
>>14334889
why can't they just admit that he is starwhirl the bearded
>>
>>14334848
>PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE™®© saving the day without her friends
>>
What are you guys doing for Makeover-giving?
>>
File: 1383407411650.jpg-(44 KB, 520x522, i wish i was a pony.jpg)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
>>14334887
Nah man I didn't lost faith, it's only that it has been a long time since I watched an actual new episode, and it feels good to watch some new footage.
>>
File: 1383407449083.gif-(1.74 MB, 400x225, 1366115238963.gif)
1.74 MB
1.74 MB GIF
>>14334875
>Appledash making a comeback

Time for best S1 ship to return to it's former glory.
>>
>>14334895
I fear that this will happen.

What the fuck, Meghan?
>>
>>14334896
Why is Makeover-giving in the middle of Dashvember?
>>
>>14334881
Your problem is that you think of their joking as an attempt at genuine humor. A lot of the time, they're just using "humor" as a way of expressing hate.
>>
>>14334885
Starswirl's book. Maybe instead of letters Twi will be writing spells at the end of each episode?
>>
File: 1383407532842.png-(235 KB, 438x407, 1381021964846.png)
235 KB
235 KB PNG
>>14334866
It's called "bulking", anon

>>14334830
I don't really care about the whole "PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE™" thing but holy crap that part looked pretty cool
>>
>>14334906
That's a made up month. The only moth and holiday Dash has is Dash history month.
Please stop trying to change the calendar.
>>
Who is ready for PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE to save the day.


Oh and the other ones will be there too.
>>
>>14334905
Uh, hey, it hasn't happened yet. I don't want it to happen either, but I think it's a little early for
>What the fuck, Meghan?
given what you're complaining about has, again, yet to occur
>>
>>14334908
>after sort of getting one spell together somehow suddenly she can make all the magic
I want theories to go
I don't need my hype to decrease any further
>>
>>14334918
you dropped these:


®
©
>>
>>14334916
Dashvember has been the month for centuries. Are you confused? Have you hit your head?
>>
>>14334920
Meghan can't write for shit, so the first two episodes are going to be terrible.
>>
>>14334920
Season 3 opener. Even though twilight didn't save the day, her friends were worthless and didn't even do anything.
>>
>>14334932
She did Po1, so fuck you.
>>
>>14334908
Maybe if there are other unfinished spells in there she's just finishing. Otherwise I'd want spells to take a while to piece together.
>>
Is this real

https://twitter.com/HubTVNetwork/status/392811521178222592/photo/1
>>
>>14334905
>I fear that this will happen.
>will

it ALREADY HAPPENED

DYEWTS
>>
>>14334920
That's just standard procedure for some people here.
They're not that bad. That THANKS MEGHAN T-shirt is pretty cool. And you get a matching baseball cap
>>
>>14334905
Why do you think this will happen? If this was going to happen why would her friends be featured at all? In fact, in all the season premiers Twilight has gotten the majority of the spotlight because she's the main character. In S1 it was her that rounded up all the elements. In S2 she un-discorded all of others. And in S3 she did the majority of the work while her friends pretty much did nothing.
>>
>>14334940
I hope not
>>
pony replaced your blood with pineapple juice
>>
>>14334940
That's one of those OC maker games
>>
>>14334937
>her friends were worthless and didn't even do anything.

Same for the wedding.

really, she's only good for Twilight/Spike interactions
>>
>>14334938
and GIYC
still one of my absolute favorite episodes
but seriously McCarty hasn't done anything good since S1
>>
>>14334869
You'd deny other people unfs for that reason?
Dash would be ashamed.
>>
Twilight Sparkle has always been the main character of the series overall
Deal with it nerds.
>>
>>14334931
Guys it's fine
There are 6 ponies
Each pony gets 2 months
We can all share and cooperate
>>
>>14334940
Yes it is real. A real thing you can mess about with on the Hub's website.
http://www.hubworld.com/my-little-pony/shows/friendship-is-magic/games/mlpfim-ponymaker-trick-or-treat
>>
>>14334963
This
>>
Reminder that MLP is about Twilight, not her friends.
>>
>>14334964
The way it's distributed is shit.
In Rarivember.
>>
>>14334963
>>14334968
There's a difference between main character and character that always does everything while others are just kind of there doing nothing.
>>
>>14334964
But the months are of different lengths
And which pony has to put up with losing days to Background Pony Appreciation Week?
>>
File: 1383407849351.png-(1.84 MB, 1024x1024, 69823__applejack_grimdark(...).png)
1.84 MB
1.84 MB PNG
It's time.
>>
>>14334963
Yet almost always "equal" to the others.
>>
>>14334963
But Faust wanted it to be about everyone.
>>
>>14334979
>Doing nothing
DYEWTS?
>>
>>14334986
Not really.
>>
>>14334986
She is taller now and she is an alicorn.
>>
>>14334963
And episodes which focus on her are not nearly as good as the episodes which focus on other horses, with very few exceptions.

All the two-parters, adventure episodes, and finales that have focused on her have been mediocre or straight up bad. The one time a finale didn't focus on her? One of the best episodes of the entire series.

Your waifu is shit and the show improves when she's in a supporting role and not a starring one.
>>
>>14334979
See
>>14334944
>>
>>14334991
Well they didn't do shit in ACW and TCE, both of them being Meghan's 2-parters
>>
>>14334981
Well clearly that runs during Applejack's month.
>>
>>14334937
If I remember correctly, it was Spike who saved the day.
>>
File: 1383407977613.jpg-(216 KB, 719x426, 1381763564132.jpg)
216 KB
216 KB JPG
Why is she so perfect?
>>
>>14334974
Unholy McCarthy/Hasbro Alliance, pls go.
>>
>>14334991
They did nothing in the wedding, and were only barely useful in the CE
>>
>Twilight writes a sentence in a book
>becomes a princess

>Fluttershy converts a god
>?
>>
>>14334885
>>14334908
It doesn't look like Starswirl's book. That was loose, blue and spiral-bound. This one is thick and purple.
>>
>>14334931
Dashvember is a made up month only celebrated by the sick fucks that wanted to get rid of Rarvember.
>>
File: 1383408020271.jpg-(140 KB, 720x569, he's right you know.jpg)
140 KB
140 KB JPG
>>14334931
>>
>>14335005
>they didn't anything in TCE
Except they kept the crystal ponies entertained and had great interaction.

But yeah they almost didn't exist in ACW.
>>
>>14334931
>>14335027
>Dashvember
>Rarvember
How about i get a good alternative for my birthday month, instead of the two worst ones?
You know, like, applevember?
>>
>>14335007
Did you read what I wrote?
>>
>>14335023
>This one is thick and purple.
UNF
>>
>>14335003
>In S1 it was her that rounded up all the elements (who are also the other ponies)
>In S2 she un-discorded all of others

>And in S3 she did the majority of the work while her friends pretty much did nothing.
See anything different?
>>
>>14335029
Finally, someone has some sense.
>>
File: 1383408086726.png-(131 KB, 527x750, 1380489712573.png)
131 KB
131 KB PNG
>>14335015
she just is
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vc-pQsoTL9c
>>
File: 1383408115910.png-(275 KB, 1280x720, The Majestic Mare.png)
275 KB
275 KB PNG
>>14335046
She's just so... majestic
>>
>>14335020
when did she convert a god
>>
>>14335036
Only partly, I read the rest after I hit enter and then felt stupid.
>>
>>14335020
discord isn't a god, he's a spirit
>>
>>14335059
the dyewts
the dyewts
the dyewts is on fire
>>
>>14335059
dyetwswstswswtsts
>>
>>14334990
>But Faust wanted it to be about everyone.
even though she wrote the series premeir, which focused on Twilight aking friends
>>
File: 1383408191894.png-(48 KB, 120x134, 1382737743149.png)
48 KB
48 KB PNG
>>14335015
Could it be because of her pretty eyes?
>>
File: 1383408212940.png-(552 KB, 1280x960, 344993__twilight%252Bspar(...).png)
552 KB
552 KB PNG
>>14335037
Is there a problem, officer?
>>
File: 1383408216668.png-(142 KB, 500x389, tumblr_mvk3nwZLN31spg5uho1_500.png)
142 KB
142 KB PNG
>>14335038
Not really, no. Twilight has done most of the work in all of the opening while her friends played minor roles. S3 was nothing different because her friends played those same minor roles. All this is done to solidify Twilight as the main character. You can even argue they did more in S3's opening than the did in S2's because they were indisposed for the majority of the second half.
>>
>>14335067
>>14335068
well i remember when she got discord to be good but when did she convert a god?
>>
>>14335067
>>14335068
I'm gonna give him benefit of the doubt and assume he was disagreeing with the "Discord is a god" line in a really obtuse way.
>>
File: 1383408244086.png-(345 KB, 1277x720, 1379790862160.png)
345 KB
345 KB PNG
>>14335070
They really add to her cuteness
>>
>>14335069
>what is an introductory episode
>>
>>14334999
>RoH
>Bad
>>
>>14335071
Why do you people always confuse thick with fat?
>>
File: 1383408292310.png-(64 KB, 248x246, JOHN MADDEN.png)
64 KB
64 KB PNG
>>
>>14335081
RoH was mediocre, not bad. It was definitely the best of the season premieres which isn't saying much.
>>
>>14335029
What's so special about Dashvember?
>>
>>14335072
Why the fuck does that Yoshi look like Twilight?
>>
>>14335069
And she directed the rest of S1, which doesn't have her much involved unless she's needed.
>>
File: 1383408360885.gif-(588 KB, 320x240, GF insult.gif)
588 KB
588 KB GIF
>>14334136
>>
>>14335072
>Twilight has done most of the work in all of the opening while her friends played minor roles

Which is fucking stupid because Twilight is impotent without her friends, not to mention a fucking retard with zero common sense.
>>
>>14335099
that's not even kevin's art
>>
>>14335096
Is the autism awareness month.
>>
Twilight Sparkle will not outlive her friends.
>>
File: 1383408420124.jpg-(158 KB, 1000x1000, extra warm.jpg)
158 KB
158 KB JPG
>>14335096
Probably the month when Running of the Leaves takes place.
And it's also best pony month
>>
>>14335029
Nice novelty calendar.
>>
>>14335116
Right.
Rarivember.
Best pony month.
>>
File: 1383408479330.png-(357 KB, 700x700, 359409__safe_twilight%252(...).png)
357 KB
357 KB PNG
>>14335108
I don't write the episodes, I just watch them.
>>
The other five will become alicorns and princesses eventually.
>>
>>14335113
1. She sacrifices herself
or
2. All of her friends become alicorns

So, the latter happens, since Meghan wouldn't fucking do that and piss off her superiors.
>>
>>14335072
Okay, I'll rewrite them for you if it's hard to think:
>In S1, she and her friends found the elements and connected with them to defeat NMM together, withdraw friends, all's fucked, no one to defeat NMM
>S2, initially they get equal attention, friends get discorded, Twilight sort of does, thinks, saves the day with friends, withdraw friends, there's no initiative nor solution to the situation, episode doesn't work at all
>S3/ACW, friends are sort of there but don't do anything important, Twilight is sole focus for the most, situation gets resolved without the help of the friends entirely in ACW, in TCE they entertain the crystal ponies which gives her more time, not a vital role but at least something, withdraw friends - ACW works entirely with nothing different, TCE they might've had some serious problems but ultimately still not a whole lot changes, the episode could work with some small rewrites here and there
>>
>>14335131
as soon as another member of the main 6 becomes a princess I'm done with this show
>>
>>14335126
>>14335116
>best pony month
So, Applevember.
>>
>>14335133
Maybe she just isn't immortal like Celestia?
>>
File: 1383408545693.png-(271 KB, 463x326, these frames, man.png)
271 KB
271 KB PNG
>>14335126
Close, but sadly you're pretty dang wrong. Rartober was last month, dude.
>>
>>14335131
In 3 weeks
>>
>>14335140
Don't worry.
They all become princesses in the same episode.
>>
>>14335133
#2 is a good option anyway, plus it's the only way the show can end "well" at this point.

>>14335140
No you're not.
>>
>>14335141
No
That was last month.
It's canon
The Hub posted October as Applejack month

>>14335145
>Rartober
That doesn't exit
>>
File: 1383408602795.png-(436 KB, 1025x768, 1379615956875.png)
436 KB
436 KB PNG
>>14335140
See y'all tomorrow!
>>
>>14335150
ok meghan
>>
>>14335128
Yeah, I know. I'm not mad at YOU.
The show's just flat-out better when Twilight's not the focus. This has been proven over and over again throughout the series run.
>>
>>14335157
>>14335152
I never said I'd be done with MLPG, I'll come in here and shitpost daily. I won't watch the show, though. I'll read the comics until they catch up and make the other characters princesses as well.
>>
>>14335156
So what's "canon" for november?
If it's any of Rarity, Fluttershy or Dash i'm going to ignore it and declare applevember.
>>
Why are Dashfags and Rarifags fighting?

Rartober comes from an image with Rainbow Dash having a shrine to Rarity because she loves her.

You should be happy that Rarity and Rainbow Dash are in love and not fight over silly names.
>>
File: 1383408734308.jpg-(9 KB, 165x200, 1665-fap-to-it.jpg)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
>>14334283
>>
>>14335167
>I won't watch the show, though.
Yeah you will. Same as how I'm continuing to watch the show despite my annoyance at PRINCESS TWILIGHT SPARKLE™.
>>
http://areyouagarenoughdude.tumblr.com/
>>
File: 1383408781396.png-(1.01 MB, 1920x1080, 1337815304810.png)
1.01 MB
1.01 MB PNG
Dont worry if things are going bad. Pony will hug.
>>
File: 1383408783755.png-(469 KB, 723x614, Appleber.png)
469 KB
469 KB PNG
>>14335176
Nothing...yet
BUT I KNOW I'M BORN ON THE SECOND OF RARIVEMBER SO IT'S FUCKING RARIVEMBER AND YOU FAGGOTS AREN'T TAKING IT FROM ME
>>
File: 1383408800884.gif-(660 KB, 501x503, 1382674094965.gif)
660 KB
660 KB GIF
>>14335177
I'm just here to enjoy the nice weather that comes with Dashvember and waiting for the s4 premiere.
>>
>>14335181
if you can see the future then please tell me who wins the next superbowl
>>
File: 1383408837633.png-(50 KB, 257x306, 1344975350503.png)
50 KB
50 KB PNG
>>14335190
I'M BORN ON THE FIFTH OF APPLEVEMBER AND YOU RARIFAGS AREN'T TAKING IT FROM ME
>>
File: 1383408865243.gif-(1.97 MB, 720x405, 1381170475764.gif)
1.97 MB
1.97 MB GIF
>>14335189
>>
>>14335063
then who is god in the FiM universe? Discord has like infinite magic power and only the EoH can defeat him. he is pretty much god.
>>
File: 1383408872650.jpg-(54 KB, 575x393, von_millers_face_when.jpg)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>14335196
Mah Brooncs over the Shithawks, 27-21.
>>
File: 1383408912810.png-(324 KB, 1024x900, 1346302789588.png)
324 KB
324 KB PNG
>>14335139
In S1 her friends are just needed to use the the elements and fire a rainbow at NMM. Other than that they played very minor roles in the episodes outside of their initial introductions and showcasing which elements they represent.

S2's is pretty much the same. They're biggest role s in that episode was firing magic at the big bad and showcasing which elements they represent.

S3 is pretty much the same. They play these really small roles that are made to look really important to the viewer while Twilight goes off to do her thing. It's not even her that saves the crystal heart, it's Spike (and Cadence)
>>
File: 1383408934704.jpg-(197 KB, 1368x1156, NO.jpg)
197 KB
197 KB JPG
>>14335203
NIGGA IT'S RARIVEMBER
APPLEJACK GOT HER OWN MONTH LAST MONTH
>>
File: 1383408946571.png-(247 KB, 1050x804, 1351039163019.png)
247 KB
247 KB PNG
Now now, let the other pones get a month too.
>>
>>14335177
But Rarity is in love with Applejack and Dash is in love with Fluttershy
http://derpiboo.ru/461635?scope=scpe330179f7050a9f322aec4b44f3509fe368fa3306
>>
>>14335206
Pinkie is nasty.
>>
File: 1383408993439.png-(137 KB, 510x293, 1319300528692.png)
137 KB
137 KB PNG
>>
File: 1383409023516.png-(202 KB, 900x1415, 14125326376357.png)
202 KB
202 KB PNG
SPIKEVEMBER
>>
File: 1383409033164.gif-(541 KB, 1064x750, Dash being a creeper and (...).gif)
541 KB
541 KB GIF
>>14335231
Because somebody is going to post this anyway.
>>
>>14335224
Last month was Rartober.
>>
>>14335209

>no chiefs

The train has no brakes
>>
>>14335243
No it wasn't. See >>14335190

The hub said it was Appleber
>>
File: 1383409078378.png-(453 KB, 600x600, 1347187871133.png)
453 KB
453 KB PNG
>>14335224
Everybody here said Rartober and no one said otherwise, so i got nothing outta that.
Tell you what, i'll settle for Twivember or Pinkvember if any of those seem fine for you.
>>
>>14335206
Those two and Princess Platinum were my favorite things about that episode.
>>
>>14335217
I'm not arguing about how much of screentime was taken up by Twilight, but about how much her friends mattered. What they did in S1 and S2 was important, their presence was important for the episodes to work, even if they didn't get much screentime. In S3 it wasn't.
>>
>>14335235
WAKE UP
>>
>>14335254
Fine. We get Twivember but after that is Raricember.
Applejack can get September and a month in spring or whatever.
Deal?
>>
File: 1383409204454.png-(170 KB, 547x588, 1345034480212.png)
170 KB
170 KB PNG
>>14335268
It's a deal, partner.
>>
File: 1383409213430.gif-(2.44 MB, 720x405, 1381170520444.gif)
2.44 MB
2.44 MB GIF
>>14335258
I agree
>>
>>14335239
How can Spike have a month if no one gives a fuck about him?
>>
File: 1383409320143.jpg-(75 KB, 800x700, Applejack Rope Happy Smile.jpg)
75 KB
75 KB JPG
>>14335275
A pleasure doing business with you Anon.
Have an Applejack to celebrate this.
>>
>>14335226
Posting popularfag art. That is so 2011
>>
>>14335189
>>14335206
>>14335258
>>14335278

HWE is better now than it was when it first aired.

Y/N?
>>
File: 1383409440665.png-(336 KB, 1000x1000, Rarity Alicorn_Twilight W(...).png)
336 KB
336 KB PNG
>>14335226
What a couple of cute ponies
>>
File: 1383409446901.png-(1.88 MB, 2505x2505, 1382297509422.png)
1.88 MB
1.88 MB PNG
>>14335289
>>
>>14335325
It was amazing when it aired retard.
>>
>>14335330
Spike why are you hitting on Apple Bloom's daughter
>>
>>14335325
I liked it at the time too because it was very fitting for the christmas mood.
>>
>>14335325
Episode quality doesn't change with time, anon. It's not wine.
>>
>>14335325
I have no idea why, but for some reason I didn't like that episode at first. So yes for me.
>>
File: 1383409518617.png-(714 KB, 1280x720, 1326478087745.png)
714 KB
714 KB PNG
>>14335325
I loved it when it aired, though. All I remember is people complaining that it ruined the lore or something.
>>
http://www.livestream.com/nutsonclark

LoE 24h livestream event
>>
>>14335346
It sort of did ruin the lore until we all realized that it's just a fable and not actual Equestrian history.
>>
File: 1383409571680.png-(216 KB, 640x693, 1379184104951.png)
216 KB
216 KB PNG
>>14335341
He lost control of his life
>>
>>14335352
Go fuck yourself rose
>>
>>14335352
Chris-Chan is streaming today as well apparently
>>
>>14335352
>LoE
wazzat
>>
>>14335325
The only thing that would be HWE a 8/10 and not a 6/10 if Merriweather didn't add that retarded window part at the end of the episode. Have the episode ended when the song end and it would be fine.
>>
>>14335362
Wait what? Really?
>>
>>14335354
Actually, it's mostly accurate history, that's the point of the flaming heart in the sky.
>>
>>14335364
It's the new LoL
>>
>>14335364
Shitty pony RP chatroom disguised as an MMORPG
>>
File: 1383409659484.gif-(1.39 MB, 444x274, Who's a silly pony.gif)
1.39 MB
1.39 MB GIF
>>14334872
yes
soon we shall pone like it was 2011
>>
>>14335354
I honestly don't see how, though.
>>
>>14335376
what
explain
>>
File: 1383409712993.gif-(1.71 MB, 220x124, 1382809259233.gif)
1.71 MB
1.71 MB GIF
>>14335362
Oh god
>>
>>14335362
link?
>>
>>14335373
Saw a thread on /v/, didn't look much into it. Check the catalog, maybe it's still there.
>>
>>14335354
I agree with you about the whole fable thing, but we can't exactly say it's canon that it's a story for foals. Just sayin', calling it a fable only holds up because of plausible deniability
>>14335381
>>14335382
LoL's a MMORPG?
>>
Anyone have that image of dash getting kissed on the frog?
>>
>>14335400
>>14335373
>>14335402
Here's the archived thread
https://archive.foolz.us/v/thread/216326213/
>>
>>14335405
>LoL's a MMORPG
It's a pile of fucking shit, but why not? It has the grinding and it's a skinner box. Fits pretty well.
>>
>>14335354
How the fuck did it ruin lore?
>>
we need to get rid of AppleDan he's not doing anything
>>
>>14335417
>CWC is a Dash and Apple fag
>>
>>14335421
We've adapted since, but we used to assume something like Celestia and Luna have either always ruled over Equestria, or for a really really long time, and some fanon said they united the races.
>>
>>14335421
Celestia and Luna created the world and the ponies and we're supposed to believe that a bunch of unicorns raised the sun and moon and not the Gods.
>>
Think the flying in that promo is going to just be her gliding or actual flying?
>>
>>14335437
>we used to assume something like Celestia and Luna have either always ruled over Equestria

"we" didn't.

In Return of Harmony, BEFORE Hearth's Warming Eve, Celestia herself says that Discord ruled Equestria before she and Luna turned him to stone.
>>
>>14335437
Yeha see the whole Luna and Celestia thing kind died when Celestia said that before them Discord ruled the land and ponies in RoH which happened long before the HWE and that fanon was retarded just for that.
>>
>>14335440
>>14335437
The way I see it, everything about that is true, but then Discord came about and Celestia and Luna were created by Starswirl.
>>
File: 1383410047751.jpg-(1.97 MB, 2816x1880, sent that bitch a cake.jpg)
1.97 MB
1.97 MB JPG
It's almost my birthday! Who can I get to do something personal for me? I've always wanted a special gift from my friends on my birthday.
>>
>>14335460
>Celestia and Luna were created by Starswirl
>Two alicorns created by one unicorn who wasn't smart enough to become an alicorn himself
w h a t
>>
File: 1383410119072.png-(72 KB, 815x645, snips.png)
72 KB
72 KB PNG
THE MAIN CAST ACCORDING TO MLP:
The Main Six
Spike
the CMC
Big Mac and Granny Smith
Mayor Mare
Mr. and Mrs. Cake
Zecora
Snips and Snails

SNIPS AND SNAILS
>>
File: 1383410148876.jpg-(316 KB, 800x2400, tall.jpg)
316 KB
316 KB JPG
The main thing I'm hoping for in S4 is more information on Starswirl I just love this mystery surrounding him, and even if they don't outright tell us more about him I would like him and the things surrounding him to get more focus
>>
>>14335464
Man I don't fucking know.

I'm just trying to make sense on why did Clover and Luna know about him.
>>
File: 1383410157281.png-(187 KB, 900x768, Not Good at Wings Yet.png)
187 KB
187 KB PNG
>>14335449
It looked like she was just falling with style.
>>
>>14335477
they finally graduated from secondary characters
>>
>>14335464
Well he never found out how he could become an alicorn. Making alicorns is something totally different.
But the whole thing is kinda nutty so I don't know what he was talking about anyway.
>>
>>14335483
Clover was his student.

All we know as far as Luna goes is that she knows what he's supposed to look like.

Just like Twilight knows what he's supposed to look like.
>>
>>14335453
>>14335459
Yes, well, after that we assumed it was just chaos before them, whatever, you can start talking about how our view of their past changed after every single episode. RoH and HWE were pretty close together in regards of airing date.
>>
File: 1383410231981.gif-(1.3 MB, 388x300, Applejack noooo.gif)
1.3 MB
1.3 MB GIF
>>14334731
>season 4
ffffffffuck...
>>
>>14335483
Well Luna could have just known the same way Twilight knew. BY READING A BOOK.
She just said her costume was good.
>>
>>14335482
We'll probably get some name drops like in s2, hinting involvement in a lot of things, but no conclusive stuff.
>>
>>14335460
>>14335464
I've always preferred the idea that the six ponies in the play became Celestia and Luna after they used the Elements to beat Discord.

Unfortunately, I don't have much (if anything) to back it up; we need a few more Luna and Celestia-centric episodes to learn about their personalities first, and information would probably come from those episodes that grinds the above guess into the dirt.
>>
>>14335464
>>14335486
This was before MMC came out mind you. really didn't think about it much after that.
>>
File: 1383410263278.gif-(249 KB, 500x500, buggin.gif)
249 KB
249 KB GIF
>>14335485
>they finally graduated from secondary characters
I know
they're in the same tier now as fucking zecora or big mac
TRULY THIS IS THEIR TIME TO SHINE
>>
>>14335506
>six ponies becoming two

That's a terrible idea.
>>
>>14335499
I really don't know where are you getting that "we" since I was here for a long time and those things were never that popular.

And no RoH and HWE weren't that close. It was 4 months between them
>>
>>14335483
I think it's a bit of a lost cause, sadly. The initial comprehensive canon that was originally planned kinda fell out of importance, and gradually writers took liberties where they could.
I don't think there'll ever be a really sensical explanation for Starswirl at this point. Damn shame, but hopefully the show's slice-of-life stuff holds up.
>>14335506
That's not bad I guess. I don't really like character fusion, though, because I've never been able to really figure out how it worked.
I know, "it's magic" etc., but like, do two personalities merge? Do they just kind of inhabit the same brain? What? It's never sat right with me.
>>
File: 1383410411131.jpg-(10 KB, 250x263, Akamai.jpg)
10 KB
10 KB JPG
>>14335514
Not if it's anything like Bionicle.
>>
>>14335506
Kinda falls flat when Celestia said that she and Luna found the Elements.
>>
>>14335527
What did we think about the history of Equestria before RoH then, if not that?
>>
File: 1383410453835.gif-(114 KB, 500x500, MAKUTABONES.gif)
114 KB
114 KB GIF
>>14335540
My negroid compatriot
>>
>>14335540
Goddamn I used to have that.
>>
File: 1383410538805.png-(487 KB, 995x1803, my_little_toa__unity_is_m(...).png)
487 KB
487 KB PNG
>>14335540
so what would the pony version look like?
>>
hearth's warming eve was one of the last episodes lauren was especially involved in

she intended for it to be backstory for the world
>>
>>14335514
Well, it at least explains how it only takes one of them to use the Elements, and how two Alicorns came about so long before Starswirl's spell was complete.

>>14335536
Ponies get very, very old, we know from Granny Smith and Inkwell. They might have figured it was time to take the responsibility of the sun and moon out of the hands of a single race, dropped off their mortal shell and minds, and fused their souls. Still all mostly-baseless conjecture, of course.

>>14335541
Spoiler for Dust: An Elysian Tail: Dust still talked about things Cassius and Jin had done as if he had done it himself; I'm thinking the six leaders found the elements.
>>
>>14335513

I want to hug snails
>>
>>14335497
>>14335483

...Who the fuck is Clover?
>>
>>14335571
It's kinda stupid since we don't know how long it was between the events of the play and Discord's rule. Also I'm sure Discord would have made some kind of comment about that.
>>
File: 1383410708344.gif-(805 KB, 348x324, Applejack is excite.gif)
805 KB
805 KB GIF
>>14335500
>season 4
>>
>>14335561
dat citation
>>
File: 1383410766855.gif-(1.08 MB, 276x260, 1334955424037.gif)
1.08 MB
1.08 MB GIF
>>14335583
>...Who the fuck is Clover?
>>
>>14335585
Why would he have? What situation have we seen him in where a comment about Celestia and Luna's origins would have been appropriate or necessary?
>>
File: 1383410841033.png-(471 KB, 487x565, 1382052842577.png)
471 KB
471 KB PNG
>>14335561
Well, as psyched as I would have been to have her actual headcanon, she beefed big time in not explaining the two godlike beings that CURRENTLY rule, in addition to the discrepancy pointed out in >>14335459
>>14335571
You misunderstand, I was basically repeating >>14335514 but with elaboration on why I didn't like it.
Also, her canon name is "Raven," now, if you care. Could be a Lyra situation, though. I rather like the sound of "Raven Inkwell."
>>14335583
Clover the Clever, the advisor pony to Princess Platinum Twilight played in the play.
>>
Holy shit, SCP is down.
>>
>>14335583
Watch the show.
>>
>>14335583
Clover the Clever
Platinum's friend/assistant/something close since she was the one that went with Platinum to find new lands and apprentice to Starswirl the Bearded.

>>14335599
Well Jeez I don't know maybe when he escaped since you know it's kinda of a big deal if there were 6 of them when he was defeated and suddenly they combined. Something like so which one of you kept control or something.

Also the stained glass shows them as one while using the elements on Discord.
>>
>>14333927
low budget and the target audience is kids
>>
>>14333952
They can get a bit much sometimes but if it bothers you that much it's Price more than anybody. He favors very busy panels and lots of references. It very rarely distracts me from the story too much
>>
>>14335610
>Also, her canon name is "Raven," now, if you care. Could be a Lyra situation, though. I rather like the sound of "Raven Inkwell."
I was talking about the extremely old teacher at Celestia's School.

>>14335618
>Also the stained glass shows them as one while using the elements on Discord.
That might be how they remember it. Or perhaps they just figured it would be better if nobody questioned why there were six in the stained glass if only two that anybody knew of had beaten Discord.
>>
I would really like another episodes like HWE. Learning about the history of Equestria is really fun for me.
>>
>>14335642
How do you know the budget for the comic? It looks a lot better than a lot of the comic being put out by the Big 2.

And all ages comics are usually a lot better than the ones intended for older readers.
>>
>>14335658
Something like that Batman TAS episode where all the villains are talking about how they Almost Got Him, but with Luna, Celestia, and Discord having tea and talking about awesome shit that happened back in the day.
>>
>>14335657
Look man it's a horrible theory that is contradicted by the show and has nothing to support it.
>>
>>14335571
>Well, it at least explains how it only takes one of them to use the Elements, and how two Alicorns came about so long before Starswirl's spell was complete.

Celestia could only use them the once like that, and lost control of them afterwards.

And that doesn't help explain Cadance at all.
>>
>>14335658
You're getting your PRINCESS TWILIGHT and you're going to deal with it. The "Castle-Mania" episode? It's just to fix and decorate the old castle in the Everfree so that PRINCESS TWILIGHT can live there.
>>
>>14335680
>and lost control of them afterwards.
what
>>
pony says you are terrible at equestria history
did you sleep through class
>>
So we're definitely getting at least one more promo from EW based on last season, but how many more do you think we'll be getting apart from that?
>>
Don't worry.

Your "Equestrian History" will be filled with pop-culture jokes and 80s Highschool drama.
>>
File: 1383411398762.png-(623 KB, 2080x2800, Twilight thread.png)
623 KB
623 KB PNG
>>14335513
>>14335477
Well, they had to do something to give the mccarthy drones a defense against the show having it's title changed.
>>
>>14335697
Don't judge me pony, it's a medical condition, I just can't help it that I fall asleep during class...
Please help me pass this exam
>>
>>14335686
I don't mind that. I really have no problems with Princess Twilight.
>>
>>14335705
Well seeing how before S2 we got a whole minute of GODDAMN DISCORD I'm kinda excited and think we'll get something substantial.
>>
File: 1383411455324.gif-(356 KB, 561x738, 348108__safe_animated_mem(...).gif)
356 KB
356 KB GIF
>>
>>14335677
>theory

It's just a fun idea, anon. No need to get your panties twisted.

>>14335680
I don't think ANYTHING explains Cadance, honestly, short of Celestia getting frisky with one of her subjects.

>>14335680
>>14335691
How long did it take her to lose control? Did she lose it immediately? Or did the connection fade over hundreds of years? Or did the three ponies she had to help her with the other half of the elements die of old age?
>>
>>14335705
The episodes will leak the week before airdate.
>>
>>14335657
Oops.
What was up with her eye exactly, anyway? Was she blind in it or something? I didn't even notice it until was pointed out, must have thought she was blinking or something.
>>14335680
Fuck Cadence's impact on the canon, seriously. If she'd just been a fucking pegasus like she was supposed to be, it'd be just THAT much easier for everything to make sense.
Gaaaaaahhhh. At least Shiny's cool.
>>
>>14335720
>doesn't loop
>frames change so quickly that I don't even know what I was supposed to see on those 4chan caps
0/10
>>
>>14335721
>Or did the three ponies she had to help her with the other half of the elements die of old age?
The fuck are you talking about?
She used all six elements on her own to defeat Nightmare Moon and she used three while Luna used the other three on Discord.
The goddamn writers said that.
>>
File: 1383411590625.jpg-(199 KB, 1200x900, 04-38,39.jpg)
199 KB
199 KB JPG
>>14335721
She went to the Matrix and became an alicorn for making love to an evil enchantress.
>>
>>14335737
I'm sorry I don't follow every interview ever done, anon. I'm just going by what I know from the show.
>>
>>14335726
Inkwell's eye was injured during the defense of Canterlot.
>>
>>14335707
>implying that wouldn't be cool as fuck

people that hated the comics because "muh out of place references" need to take a god damn chill pill.
>>
File: 1383411685383.jpg-(46 KB, 600x450, how did they print a pict(...).jpg)
46 KB
46 KB JPG
>>14335462
what do you want, who's your favorite pony and what day is your birthday?
>>
File: 1383411720149.png-(25 KB, 764x439, Amy on Celestia's Po(...).png)
25 KB
25 KB PNG
>>14335750
This was posted in the general multiple times.
>>
File: 1383411748144.jpg-(7 KB, 180x149, they made several cakes.jpg)
7 KB
7 KB JPG
>>14335761
>>
I wonder if Princess Twilight will show Celestia and Luna in the past with the elements?
>>
>>14335765
Then why are we even discussing the cause of Celestia losing control over the elements if she never actually lost that control?
>>
There is a time and place for ponies. The time is now. The place is here
-Me
>>
File: 1383411832395.jpg-(2.49 MB, 3000x2439, vintage pony.jpg)
2.49 MB
2.49 MB JPG
>>14335770
that's genius
>>
>>14335784
I don't know especially since it's said she never lost control over them in RoH.
>>
>>14335789
But she did say she lost her connection to them in RoH
>>
File: 1383411888329.png-(98 KB, 480x480, 1372230328668.png)
98 KB
98 KB PNG
>>14335737
>>14335765
That sounds p. good, but that still doesn't explain what we were talking about earlier: where she and Luna were during the events of the Hearth's Warming Eve story, assuming you think it's not just a story.
>>
>>14335765
this is how it is in my head canon, a powerful celestia.

but they make her so weak in the show every single villain defeats her and celestia is useless in every situation.

i get she has to let twilight solve ever little problem for some reason but come on give us something.
>>
>>14335789
The problem is this guy >>14335680

>>14335796
After dealing with Luna, or after they were taken up by the six we know and love?
>>
>>14335796
Yes. When Twilight and her friends used them. That's when they changed owners and the spell holding Discord started weakening since the elements changed owners.
>>
>>14335799
It was before Discord ruled even, they didn't exist yet. Technically they could've existed but if they did, nobody knew about them
>>
>>14335799
>where she and Luna were during the events of the Hearth's Warming Eve story

Not born yet.
>>
>>14335813
>>14335812
Yeah, this works!
Oh man, what if in season 4 we get an episode about how Discord came to be/came to power? We ARE supposed to be getting a bunch of episodes with him, so the chances aren't too bad.
Hype meter: 65%
>>
>>14335765
>>14335784
You'll note that Amy uses "I actually think."

It's more canon than most fan speculation since she's a writer, but it's less canon than the actual show.

Someone should as Lauren about it.
>>
>>14335831
>lauren
Lauren has nothing to do with the show anymore.
>>
>>14335830
You do realize pretty much all worldbuilding we've gotten in about one and a half years has been rubbish?
>>
>>14335765
It's sad if you imagine Twilight failing to make friends and Celestia stepping in to banish Luna again.
>>
>>14335830
>we know he gets a song
>his pose in RoH is like he was in the middle of a song
I am very optimistic about this
>>
>>14335830
>world building
>MLP after S2 or S1 depending on who you ask
>>
>>14335835
>implying you should care about what others have to say
On the other hand
>implying Lauren gives a shit at this point
>>
>>14335831
That'd still be less canon than the actual show, sadly. I consider her basically on level with the other show writers these days.
Plus, she might not be too happy about it.
>missing my four-legged girls. Thinking I always will :(
>>14335841
>>14335852
35% is a big amount of anti-hype considering it's ponies, anon.
I'm basically obsessed with the damn things.
>>14335851
I'm not so optimistic about the singing, frankly. But I've been surprised by this show before lots, so we'll see.
>>
>>14335858
Yes we should care about what others say since THEY STILL WORK ON THE SHOW AND LAUREN'S WORD MEANS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING RIGHT NOW
>>
>>14335858
faustdrone pls go
>>
>>14335850
>tfw no episode where Twilight and friends go to an alternate universe when this happens and Alt!Twilight turns into another Sunset Shimmer
>>
>>14335850
>Celestia thought that she would be with her sister again
>instead she has to banish her for another 1000 years while she is still under NMM's influence
>she can't even say sorry
>because Twilight failed to make friends
>>
File: 1383412403953.png-(50 KB, 148x138, Scared man.png)
50 KB
50 KB PNG
If we cared more about just seeing cute ponies and didn't give two shits about "lore" and "story" we wouldn't have these annoying,boring,dumb arguments.
>>
>>14335761
Well a drawing would be nice and so would anything else.

My favorite pony is best Rarity.

November 19.
>>
>>14335879
But Twilight has nothing in common with Sunset other than both being great at magic.
Sunset was always a power hungry bitch.
Twilight was a nerd that read to much and had gained a love of magic and studying after seeing Celestia raise the sun as a filly.
>>
>>14335891
Then this fucking board wouldn't exist, shithead.
>>
>>14335900
So this entire board is based upon story and worldbuilding and not just the existence of the show?
>This fucking board wouldn't exist
That's a good thing.
>>
>>14335761
Not that guy but can I get a Rarity, Twilight and Sweetie doing something cute together for today?
Please?
>>
>>14335891
>annoying,boring,dumb
I'm having fun, though.
>>
>>14335899
Yeah, and then becomes cold and realizes that power is the best way than making friends.
>>
can we be lewd now?
mlpg is boring when it's about show talk
>>
>>14335928
go away ruseman
>>
>>14335914
Me too
>arguing about a cartoon about ponies here is the most fun part of the day on my birthday
i think I fucked up somewhere in my life.
>>
>>14335928
Go fuck yourself, faggot.

Seriously. Mc fucking kill yourself.
>>
>>14335891
FIM didn't get popular by being just about cute ponies though
>>
>>14335943
>>14335933
this is all just rehashed discussion anyways.
everything people here are talking about has already been talked about multiple times
>>
File: 1383412797599.jpg-(38 KB, 328x368, woody-180761.jpg)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
>>14335786
Watch out, AJ! There's a snake in your hat!
>>
>>14335879
>>14335899
>>14335924
I doubt Twilight Sparkle would have become power-hungry like Sunset Shimmer, even if she failed the Nightmare Moon event. She was always more sociable and friendly.

The bigger change would have been on Celestia, probably. I don't know that she would have kicked Twilight out of her student position, since part of the reason she was watching Twilight was her immense magical potential, but she'd probably have become more distant about it and give Twilight less important duties.
>>
File: 1383412861780.png-(71 KB, 186x339, comet tail is not amused.png)
71 KB
71 KB PNG
>>14335891

but these were always the most fun discussions

not that other types are not fun as well
>>
>>14335955
Not everyone has been there from the start like you have.
>>
I've had it. I'm filtering show discussion along with satyrs and batponies and drugs and centaurs and music and Celestia and Gaffer.
>>
>>14335924
But she never wanted friends. Nor power. Just knowledge.

You want an alternate universe? Fine. Twilight fucks up finding friends,tries to defeat NMM alone, Celestia is defeated by NMM, she rules Equestria and Twilight retreats in the Everfree alone and becomes a great mage with books she manage to recover from various places in Eqeustria and continues studying not carying about friendship because that failed the first time
Also her would be friends now hide with Zecora because they are important and I doubt the show would go Shaolin Showdown and have them die in front of Twilight holy shit that part was dark and cold.


Also you know how many problems would this raise?
Okay Discord wouldn't escape since he Elements don't change owners so there's no reason for the spell to weaken.
But Sombra? He'd return. So you have a war between Nightmare Eqeustria and The Crystal kingdom under Sombra.
>>
>>14335975
She'd go back to Canterlot if she failed right?
>>
File: 1383412941477.jpg-(29 KB, 338x475, 1382526985901.jpg)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>>14335985
>>
>>14335891
Is this going to be the new shitposting thing?
>you shouldn't care about the writing in the slightest, just like me
>>
>>14335985
...
What's left?
>>
>>14335996
Smut, meta drama, and off topic?
>>
>>14335994
>You have to absolutely care about the writing or else you don't actually like the show
>>
>>14335988
Wasn't it said that Celestia could've defeted NMM on her own if Twilight failed?
>>
>>14336011
Yeah but I'm talking about bad future alternate universe.
>>
>>14335992
Oh my god, this is so cute!

>Pokémon Tales (Japanese: ポケモンえほん Pokémon Picture Book) are a series of children's picture books published by VIZ Media in North America and Shogakukan in Japan. A small number of artists collectively provided illustrations across the series, many of which have since become established within the Pokémon franchise. Each book contains a story focusing on one Pokémon, such as a Squirtle afraid to come out of his shell or a hungry Snorlax.

I MUST HAVE THEM
>>
>>14336010
>only extremes exist
>logical counterarguments don't matter
yes, shitposting alright
>>
>MT drew the readdit meme mascot
>uniconically


FUCK THE WORLD

http://31.media.tumblr.com/c22f2c0c310d70f760c8d322facfa7be/tumblr_mvmn3jmA8z1rss0c2o5_500.png
>>
>>14336026
sure it's uniconic, it's just a weird monster version of it
>>
The thing you can infer from Amy's hypothesis on Celestia's power is that Celestia could use all the Elements together, but only to banish Nightmare Moon. She wasn't able to use them to bring Luna back, which is why she needed Twilight to make friends capable of wielding them.

That's what Celestia has been wanting for 1000 years. Her little sister back. It's all she ever wanted.
>>
>>14335991
Most likely. Depends where she fucks up
>Doesn't make friends
She'd go back to Canterlot
>Makes friends but fails to use the elements
I could see her asking Celestia to let her stay in Ponyville. Especially now that she fucked up one of the main reasons she was being trained.
>>
>>14336026
Why do you care tho?
>>
>>14336022
Is it shitposting because it doesn't agree with your views?
>>
>>14336026
how is that not a good allegory towards reddits' elitism?
>>
>>14336026
Those designs looked pretty cool.
I wonder if that's for a game of some sort.
>>
>>14336026
>what if reddit was filled with /v/irgins
>>
File: 1383413241305.png-(365 KB, 841x950, 1350688092442.png)
365 KB
365 KB PNG
>>14335786
>>14335786
Such a peace place. I would love to live there with that pony.
>>
>>14336019
Twilight moving away from Ponyville because she failed could still be a "bad future" for her. It could even lead to Chrysalis invading Canterlot and winning, or the Sombra thing too. Your idea sounds more interesting though.
>>
>>14336047
It's the 4chan habit which consists in hating everything related to reddit.
>>
I still want to eat out of MT's butthole.
>>
>>14336048
Is there anything stereotypical for shitposting that you haven't done yet? Oh yeah, call people bronies, but that doesn't work here since it's you that supposedly cares less about the contents of the show.
>>
>>14336026
She drew it as a weird ugly thing, I don't think it's a very positive "I like you reddit, do you like me too?"-type of image
>>
>>14336059
Hmm never thought of Chrysalis. I mean if we go with the NMM route if she wins Chrysalis would have no reason to invade Equestria.

but if we go down on the Celestia defeats NMM route Chrysalis would still ne a threat.

I think that Celestai would defeat her tough.
Think about it. Scenario is Twilight fucks up so Celestia reuses the elements to banish NMM again. That means she'd have the Elements again. So since she would be the last line of defense from the start she'd probably get the Elements first to use them.

Even so if Twilight was from the start in Canterlot that means she'd find out Chrysalis plan sooner so she'd spend much much less time siphoning Shining Armor's love so she'd be weaker then she was in the show. Her plan would be ruined from the start.
>>
>>14336110
Right, forgot about that. But I thought Celestia lost her connections to the EoH when she sent Luna to the moon?
>>
>>14336081
You still haven't explained why saying that I only enjoy specific content of the show is shitposting.

I don't even call people bronies, in fact people
>>14334576

have called me a brony simply because I do not care for the story at all.
>>
>>14336125
Not really. The show is kinda iffy about when she lost connection with the elements. It could be then or it could be when Twilight and her friends took control over them.
Eitherway Amy says that Celestia would be capable of using them again on NMM so it's not an issue.
>>
File: 1383413787635.jpg-(19 KB, 320x223, Drew.jpg)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
"Things you shouldn't do to a pony"
>>
>>14336154
sex
>>
>>14336154
Touch their flanks without permission.
>>
>>14336142
Hmm. That would leave Sombra coming back and wrecking shit.
>>
>>14336154
huh I'm watching Whose Line right now.
>>
>>14336154
cuddle
>>
>>14336167
Assuming Celestia brought Luna back, they could just get rid of him again.
>>
>>14336167
Celestia could fuck him with the Elements.
I mean Luna and Celestia defeated him without the elements but since Celestia could defeat NMM with the Elements I'd think she could fuck him up too.
>>
>>14336159
>>14336165
>>14336168
>>14336169

You all fail. Turn in your badges and clear out your desks.
>>
File: 1383413998722.jpg-(183 KB, 1227x766, not the ultimate showdown.jpg)
183 KB
183 KB JPG
>>14336182
But she would have only been able to banish Nightmare Moon again. She couldn't bring Luna back by herself.
>>
File: 1383414083011.jpg-(44 KB, 500x281, tumblr_mv8co3mtvF1r72tn9o1_500.jpg)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
>>14336154
Use them as currency
>>
>>14336202
This always bothered me.

Why couldn't Celestia use the elements to bring luna back, but the Main 6 could?
>>
>>14336135
The simple reason is that you're saying your supposed view should be the view of everyone else too as it's superior, and at least twice you immediately jumped to extremes to prove the other party wrong.
Furthermore the brony insult is really appropriate in a non-insult way for you, since it's the bronies that love the shit out of ponies regardless of pretty much any circumstance. Writing is shit? No problem. Presentation sucks? It's ponies, man, it doesn't matter!
>>
>>14336218
Because she wasn't attuned to all the elements. She couldn't work in complete harmony.

If she could use the elements to change Luna back, she would have done it 1000 years ago.
>>
>>14336220
Yeah, bronies are dumb autists who enjoy every fucking shit they eat.

Do you know why /co/ fucking likes it and it isn't a fucking fetish discussion like Shezow?
>>
>>14336202
>>14336218
It actually makes a bit of sense. Assuming what Amy said is worth giving a shit about, it was Luna accepting Celestia's friendship that made her transform back. It would've been somewhat harder to think about friendships when fighting that specific pony. In other words, Luna/NMM's hatred and anger was directed at others at the time.
>>
>>14336154
beb
>>
>>14336220
So I can't like the show and I absolutely have to enjoy it the way you enjoy it?
Also I never said that I'm superior I'm just saying if we were more focus on the ponies and less on the writing we wouldn't engage in huge shitflinging and headcanon that always takes place.

If you care that deeply for great writing then why even come to a kid's show? I don't really care for the writing but I'm pretty certain that it doesn't match up nearly to other shows.

You're watching a very long commercial, not a fantasy epic.
>>
>>14336260
See, extremes and backpedaling and strawman again.
>>
pony says you are a foolish fool who is foolishly fooled by foolish fool's fooling
>>
>>14336291
Pony might be right
>>
>>14336243
So basically, Twilight doing everything she did was pointless?
>>
>>14336291
Shut up Dash
>>
>>14336300
Yes.
>>
>>14336300
Well, not really, because if Celestia had done it, Luna would've been much more likely to just end up being banished again. The fact that it was Twilight instead of Celestia fighting NMM could've helped turning Luna back, is what I'm saying.
>>
>>14336274
Explain what extremes that I present?
You're telling me that I cannot enjoy the show simply because I only enjoy one part of it, otherwise why engage in argument for someone who just likes something else about the show?
>backpedaling
>straw man
explain where I did both of these.
>>
>>14336216
>it's dangerous to go to cons
>take this
>>
>>14336291
Is pony trying to fool me again?
>>
What do the EoH even do?
>>
PONY! POOOONY!

WHERE'S MY HOT POCKET? I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR HALF AN HOUR!
>>
>>14336360
They create some rainbow thing that.. no, I don't know. That solves problems in whatever way is suitable.
>>
>>14336360
Friendship-based portable maser cannon.
>>
>>14336360
A fucking rainbow laserbeam.

That's the fucking purpose for it.
>>
File: 1383415002870.jpg-(90 KB, 569x772, 1378243569427.jpg)
90 KB
90 KB JPG
beep
>>
Fuck you, princess Twilight. Just fuck you and you're fucking wings, you fuck.
>>
>>14336406
Friendship is magic. Luna is 8 bits
>>
I don't even know why Twilight is wearing the crown thing outside promoting the toys because she can activate it without wearing it as seen in EG.

Shit, she doesn't even need the other elements to do the rainbow laser bull crap.
>>
File: 1383415203980.png-(132 KB, 429x463, mistake.png)
132 KB
132 KB PNG
>>14336432
>EG
>anything consistent with the original show
>especially re: the EoH
>>
>>14336432
Yes, but the others still do.
She keeps the crown because she's a princess, now.
>>
>>14336455
It's canon.
>>
>>14336455
IT'S CANON
SORRY NIGGA
>>
>>14336238
Implying we never go into fetish discussion
>>
File: 1383415267264.png-(130 KB, 700x700, 1381259670672.png)
130 KB
130 KB PNG
>>
>>14336462
>>14336461
BUT
>>
>>14336458
She doesn't need the others neither do the others need their elements
>>
>>14336461
>>14336462
Except it contradicts the main show, which is a higher tier of canon, especially with regards to the future of the main show (Season 4).
>>
File: 1383415395992.jpg-(28 KB, 357x281, 1337567056096.jpg)
28 KB
28 KB JPG
>>14336455
Except it's canon to FIM.

Twilight went to a "human" high school, fell in "love" with a "human", activated the Elements without the crown (or the other jewels, or even the other wielders) and gained pretty wings while in human form.

>>14336483
EG is part of the show. It's set between S3 and S4. Like it or not, it's part of the cartoon.
>>
File: 1383415419243.jpg-(924 KB, 1040x1600, 004.jpg)
924 KB
924 KB JPG
So why is Giddilee's cutie mark a saddle with a stirrup?
>>
>>14336476
>>14336483
No, you see, the point is that it can't and mustn't be canon and to popularize this fact it's a good idea to point out the flaws.
It isn't below the main show in franchise canon as per Meghan McCarthy.
>>
File: 1383415447499.png-(260 KB, 671x553, 1364599557456.png)
260 KB
260 KB PNG
So I had a rather unpleasant dream last night where Pinkie Pie was given wings against her will. She locked herself in a room and amputated them herself only to find out that they grow back.
>>
>>14336499
Because she's into BDSM.
>>
File: 1383415480638.gif-(1.43 MB, 500x281, 1344609225442.gif)
1.43 MB
1.43 MB GIF
>>
>>14336507
You had a vision of when she becomes an alicorn.
>>
File: 1383415560326.gif-(87 KB, 256x192, edgeworth-confident(b).gif)
87 KB
87 KB GIF
>>14336496
>Like it or not, it's part of the cartoon.
Where is your proof? Until you provide evidence, everything you say is conjecture
>>
>>14336507
Remember when rose used to be cool?
>>
>>14336360
They shoot plot-resolving lazor beemz at any hanging plot point that needs resolution.
>>
>>14336496
>Except it's canon to FIM.
No it's not. Lower tier.
And it's not "part of the show" by virtue that it is literally not part of the show, it's a spin-off movie.
>>14336501
Well, it would be shitty if it was canon, to be sure, but it's not. Different media of the same franchise have different tiers of canon, and since EqG 1) came out later than the main show and 2) contradicted the main show, it's very easy to say that it will not be canon to season 4.
>>
>>14336507
Congrats, you're a seer.
>>
File: 1383415647775.gif-(983 KB, 450x252, Luna1.gif)
983 KB
983 KB GIF
http://mlpg.co/q/res/500761.html
>>
>>14336531
Remember when 4chan was cool?
>>
>>14336531
yeah i remember today
>>
>>14336551
>Luna
tom hanks
>>
S1E1 through S2E24 == Canon
S2E25 through S3E13 == Fanfiction
Comix == Fanfiction of fanfiction
EqG == Fanfiction nobody wanted or asked for
>>
>>14336527
McCarthy said so on Twitter, it's somewhere on her twitter.
>>14336535
The movie was not a spinoff, it was the introduction of a potential spinoff. It had parts set in the pony universe. Again, according to McCarthy, it's literally right there in the middle of the timeline between S3 and S4, and as sad as it is, there is no grounds whatsoever to argue against it. Technically it came out later only in the same sense S4 came out later than S3.
>>
>>14336527
Meghan(or someone else from staff) said that it took place after Twilight's ceremony at the end of MMC. She's having trouble with her wings, which is a plot point in season 4's premier episode.

It's probably not going to get referenced that much if at all, but it is canon that Twilight turned human and back to pony.
>>
>>14336571
you==brony
>>
>>14336571
I like this
>>
File: 1383415825257.gif-(25 KB, 256x192, Phoenix_Head_Shake.gif)
25 KB
25 KB GIF
>>14336527
I cannot provide the proof.
>>
>>14336584
Keep eating that Hasbrodiarrhea.
>>
>>14336584
#BURN
>>
>>14336551
>winking mare.gif
>>
File: 1383415907174.gif-(35 KB, 256x192, edgeworthDA-shrug.gif)
35 KB
35 KB GIF
>>14336572
>>14336578
>McCarthy said so on Twitter
Oh yeah? Lauren Faust said otherwise on Twitter. If your word is worth going by, so is mone
>>
>>14336594
Y-you too
No matter how many == you make, you're still watching the show in the end
>>
>>14336571
Stop calling it fanfiction.
There's a middle ground between CANON and NOT CANON. I swear to god, I'm opening paint.net right now to make that "tiers of canon" image like I said I would. This is absurd.
>>14336572
The grounds are it's a movie, and, since it's not the show, it's not the show. Simple as that. Same reason the comics aren't on the same tier as the show: they're not the show.
Canon is used to establish coherency across various media of a franchise. Therefore, if one, later arrival contradicts an earlier one, it's a lower tier.
We're /co/, we should know this already.
>>
>>14336611
>I swear to god, I'm opening paint.net right now to make that "tiers of canon" image like I said I would. This is absurd.

No anon.

This is autism.
>>
>>14336605
Who was in charge of FIM during S3, EG and now S4?
>>
Is Monsters University any good or should I skip it
>>
File: 1383416095062.gif-(35 KB, 256x192, edgeworth-shrug.gif)
35 KB
35 KB GIF
>>14336605
Lauren Faust is no longer affiliated with the show. McCarthy is still working on the show, and her word has much more influence than Lauren's, even if the crew is supposed to follow Lauren's "vision".
>>
>>14336630
It's canon
>>
>Using absolutes to sequester arguments.
>>
File: 1383416171936.jpg-(16 KB, 854x480, Season 3 episode intro.jpg)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
>>14336626
>>14336643
Take That!
Even in Season 3, Faust is still credited
>>
File: 1383416259261.png-(176 KB, 676x575, tumblr_mo78flvkob1rckw3lo(...).png)
176 KB
176 KB PNG
>>14336651
At least we're arguing about the show!
>>
File: 1383416289798.png-(278 KB, 837x402, 1383268963372.png)
278 KB
278 KB PNG
>>14336656
She "made" FIM, but that means jack shit since she doesn't actually run it after S2, or S1.
>>
>>14336666
>>
File: 1383416311411.gif-(37 KB, 256x192, edgeworth-smirka.gif)
37 KB
37 KB GIF
>>14336656
Not so fast. "Developed for Television by" means that the original idea and form was credited to someone. That someone is Lauren Faust.
That she is no longer working on it does not mean it's no longer her idea, so it stays.
>>
>>14336681
I'm not drawing much these days.
>>
Why are PW roleplays so damn funny?
>>
File: 1383416396716.gif-(30 KB, 256x192, Judge_Normal_1.gif)
30 KB
30 KB GIF
>>14336656
>>14336686
He's right. I'm afraid I will have to penalize you for this, Wright.
>>
Quit posting Ace Attorney .gifs, you're worse than avatarfags
>>
File: 1383416472939.gif-(17 KB, 256x192, edgeworthDA-deskslam.gif)
17 KB
17 KB GIF
>>14336680
>>14336686
>She "made" FIM, but that means jack shit since she doesn't actually run it after S2, or S1.
Don't be so cocky, you just contradicted yourself.
Even if she is not currently working on the whow, you have stated that the team is still following her "vision". Thus, her word is law, so to speak
>>
File: 1383416476716.gif-(12 KB, 145x151, ani-phoenix-wargg.gif)
12 KB
12 KB GIF
>>14336699
>>
File: 1383416492204.gif-(419 KB, 209x231, lightning bolt waving.gif)
419 KB
419 KB GIF
Oh wow, we're roleplaying today. Can I be this cute mare?
>>
>>14336499
She's good at steering a class of rowdy blank flank fillies and colts onto the topic of discussion. Kids that WANT to learn are more likely to learn, and be enthusiastic about it. She excels as a kindergarten or primary school teacher.
>>
File: 1383416538676.gif-(19 KB, 256x192, godot-heh mug.gif)
19 KB
19 KB GIF
>>14336703
>>
Apple Bloom and a human little girl, having a farting contest.
>>
>>14336720
>pls respond
>>
>>14336611
>The grounds are it's a movie, and, since it's not the show, it's not the show
It IS the show. It's not split up into episodes, but it's just as canon as anything else. The same staff created it, which wouldn't even be a requirement, but it just adds to that, it's not like the comics which is just sent out to a bunch of completely different people unaffiliated with the show.
If you want to talk about show canon and EG not being same tier as the show to show canon, you're still wrong for the exact same reasons, but at least not as much as when arguing franchise canon.
A very unreliable and dumb but also undisputable source said that it's fully canon, there's nothing more to it, it's not in a lower tier just 'cause. Beyond the fact that it's total shit, there's just nothing else that provides grounds for the assumption of a lower tier. A different format of presentation doesn't cut it. I already said it once, but it's just not a separate entity according to the people who make the show, not any more than an entirely pony movie would be - which wouldn't be.
>>
File: 1383416633379.gif-(10 KB, 212x160, Edgeworth-bow.gif)
10 KB
10 KB GIF
>>14336713
Laws are made to be broken. No large project or series has ever went completely along the lines of the original idea.
Even in MLP, Lauren's original idea was to almost never let ponies do anthropomorphic poses, but she was lenient enough to allow some in Season 1.
>>
>>14336703
I really hate moot for allowing avatar fagging on /mlp/. I don't mind it when it's just a few times but this has been going on for hours (or at least I assume so because they were already at it when I left a few hours ago and now that I came back half of the thread is still AA gifs)
>>
>>14336740
But you responded.
>>
>>14336520
>>14336531
>>14336543
The most disturbing part was probably after I got done trying to catch up to her she was a crying mess. I grabbed her, careful not to touch her bandaged wing stumps she wouldn't stop muttering "I don't want to change. I like myself. I like myself."
>>
>>14336761
So did you. You just got baited.
>>
>>14336713
>implying her "vision" can't be changed

See fucking Cadence. She was meant to be a unicorn, yet the powers that be changed her into an alicorn, thus making the whole "2 alicorn" thing that Faust had bullshit.
>>
>>14336759
If you ignore them, they will go away.
>>
>>14336720
Only if I can romance you.
>>
>>14336771
They probably won't since it seems to be at least two of them talking to each other.
>>
File: 1383416795031.gif-(80 KB, 256x192, phoenix-document(b).gif)
80 KB
80 KB GIF
>>14336750
That doesnt change the fact the show's law was decided by faust. The law is the law, even if it is broken
>>
I've never played a single Phoenix Wright game
>>
Why is Edgeworth arguing with himself?
>>
File: 1383416873951.jpg-(37 KB, 625x626, 1374680494452.jpg)
37 KB
37 KB JPG
>>14336769
>>
>>14336746
She said it was fully canon where? The wording of this is important. I also seem to remember her saying that EqG would have no effect on Season 4, which would effectively mean it doesn't have an impact on FiM at all.

I maintain it's a different tier because it's a movie. I don't see why this would not be the case: even a full-length pony movie would potentially be different tier of canon if it did not effect FiM at all.
>>
>>14336777
It's probably one guy samefagging
>>
>>14336789
it's defense attorney vs prosecutor
>>
File: 1383416923554.jpg-(189 KB, 954x1580, 13534643767235.jpg)
189 KB
189 KB JPG
I'LL TAKE THE CASE
>>
>>14336770
If I'm not mistaken she was supposed to be a pegasus.
I'd have preferred either, though, frankly.
>>
File: 1383416974884.jpg-(36 KB, 660x435, hurvguddnhr.jpg)
36 KB
36 KB JPG
>>14336810
HARVEY GET IN HERE
>>
File: 1383416999593.gif-(117 KB, 256x192, edgeworth-thinkinga.gif)
117 KB
117 KB GIF
>>14336786
But her own vision isn't even law. It's a guidance. If it were law, ponies would have visible genitalia.
It's true that Lauren Faust intended to have Twilight promoted through alicornhood, but she herself stated she did not intend it to be done the way Magical Mystery Cure did.
>>
>>14336787
Me neither. I stopped enjoying videogames around 7 years ago.
>>
>>14336823
Did you get that thing I sent you?
>>
File: