Posting mode: Reply
[Return]
Name
E-mail
Subject []
Comment
Verification
File
Password(Password used for file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 3072 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Read the rules and FAQ before posting.
  • このサイトについて - 翻訳


  • File : 1299724778.jpg-(971 KB, 785x2000, unstoppable_derpy.jpg)
    971 KB MLP General Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:39 No.24161445  
    Idea from a fellow Brony on XBL::

    What if there was an MLP comic book? Who would publsih it and how much would you pay? Also, what would it be about?
    >> MegaSweet !6/JhxoKXsc 03/09/11(Wed)21:40 No.24161472
    >>24161445

    BOOM Studios. They do the best TV adaptations I've seen.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:40 No.24161473
    Sometimes I wish ponies was real.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:41 No.24161487
    http://arch.413chan.net/mlpgeneral/
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:42 No.24161495
    another thread is already up:

    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324


    polite sage
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:43 No.24161529
         File1299724990.png-(78 KB, 200x194, 1299379588177.png)
    78 KB
    Made another new video.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGMSDkcmaeM
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:43 No.24161536
         File1299724993.png-(412 KB, 1200x1200, poni writes fanfiction.png)
    412 KB
    Are you guys ready for the friendoff?
    are you gonna contribute?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:45 No.24161581
         File1299725101.jpg-(43 KB, 675x504, pinkie pie on steroids.jpg)
    43 KB
    my first pony related picture
    any tips?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:45 No.24161588
         File1299725115.gif-(64 KB, 356x294, 0000ca.gif)
    64 KB
    >>24161472 BOOM Studios.

    The first story would be about how Fluttershy exploded twice.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:45 No.24161594
    >>24161536
    Doing a Kamen Rider Den-O crossover pic. A couple of /co/lts have already made crossover stories, and I know there are a couple more in the wood work.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:45 No.24161606
         File1299725144.jpg-(10 KB, 317x200, 1299276342417.jpg)
    10 KB
    >>24161516
    >>24161495
    L2Index to find the current one.

    Last OP had a topic so we let him make the next. And that other thread, just because there isn't a MLP on the front page that doesn't mean there isn't an MLP General somewhere on the board.

    Seriously: http://arch.413chan.net/mlpgeneral/
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:46 No.24161622
    Migrating this over, since I want some actual pony discussion regarding episodes:

    In terms of episodes, most of non MLP involves spotlighting a few characters.

    Between 2 - 4 characters seems really common. One character may get the most focus, but at least one other character gets quite a bit of time as well.

    At least half of this group will be of the mane cast, (CMC is a an exception. You decide for yourself if CMC is part of the them or not) This is when you flesh out characters by interaction.

    Other characters can pop in and out. These background stories have little to no back story, if they get a name at all! Sometimes, a somewhat exotic one shot character acts in a defined role. [A caveat to the "one shot" role, flashbacks and cameos are allowed. Also, until the season is over, you can't really 100% sure.] Examples include Gay Serpent, Trixie, Gilda, Great Dragon, Zecora, Hydra.

    Pony interaction depends on personality. Ponies seem to express it differently. Pinkie is by far most social, followed by Rainbow Dash. These two wrecking balls smash into episodes for little reason to make an appearance. They have other, very worthy goals, but not much time is spent that much time seeing them pursue these goals. These two are without a doubt different in personality, but they are both quite social.
    The other four do their own thing it seems, and go out to interact with others of the main cast in varying degrees.
    Twilight Sparkle, as the moral reader, is always involved in some small way. She is not considered as social because she prefers to stay at home studying magic. Some of the time she forced into interaction to accomplish a goal. Twilight Sparkle loves being with her friends, she just likes her "me" time too.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:46 No.24161628
         File1299725188.jpg-(1.53 MB, 2496x1590, Robot stuff Colored.jpg)
    1.53 MB
    so many goddamn lines in this one
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:46 No.24161631
    So, if this is the official thread, I'll repost my links from earlier.

    I'm working on a story about Pokey (the balloon-popping unicorn), and have finished two chapters so far. The story is set when he (and the rest of the 'adults' in FiM) are still in school. Any comment/criticism is appreciated.

    Part 1

    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VdoWcnz8ma-IM93j6jnvJMDcWQiYM4f52RNkfInYuTE/edit?hl=en

    Part 2

    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TMg4_DQBq1uDdC7bDMIeHbhNYQdveVtNvqk9eVmXHKk/edit?hl=en
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:46 No.24161638
    >>24161622
    Applejack, Rarity, and Fluttershy do this as well, with varying reasons of their other business. Applejack has a farm, Rarity has a salon / boutique, Fluttershy has her animal friends. These three are separated by their very divergent personality. So far, both Applejack and Rarity have had an episode focus on them completely. These two episodes, Applebuck Season and Suited for Success, are among the favorite episodes on youtube. If this trend continues, Fluttershy's focused epsidoe will always be favorite.

    So I ask you:

    What will a Fluttershy focused episode be about?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:47 No.24161656
         File1299725256.png-(51 KB, 690x359, howboutnope.png)
    51 KB
    OP here. I love you guys.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161693
         File1299725340.jpg-(38 KB, 600x338, 1299468772668.jpg)
    38 KB
    I'm bored...

    Rarity thread?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161695
         File1299725346.png-(164 KB, 329x537, 1299633663326.png)
    164 KB
    >>24161606
    I love you. Letting me make threads and whatnot.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161696
         File1299725346.png-(854 KB, 1600x900, 1299405257809.png)
    854 KB
    >>24161656
    You're welcome.

    Signed
    -General Image Holder
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161697
    >>24161622
    Twilight Sparkle does like interaction, whoever is a new world for her
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161710
         File1299725369.jpg-(220 KB, 1000x967, 129937793432.jpg)
    220 KB
    >>24161628
    ?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:49 No.24161714
         File1299725380.jpg-(16 KB, 496x286, pony13.jpg)
    16 KB
    http://vocaroo.com/?media=vtmKb01BrsDqTHeaT

    I sang Fluttershy's lullaby song. I kind of filled in how it would have sounded if Sweetie Belle didn't sing it.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:50 No.24161742
         File1299725428.jpg-(108 KB, 800x800, twixie.jpg)
    108 KB
    >> IronMane | Pony !STARK.Tubs 03/09/11(Wed)21:50 No.24161753
         File1299725450.png-(103 KB, 1020x212, temp.png)
    103 KB
    I'll just leave this here.
    http://www.ponychan.net/chan/g/res/626.html
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161763
         File1299725471.jpg-(29 KB, 269x269, 1299571092320.jpg)
    29 KB
    >>24161696
    >>24161693
    Responding to two posts with one picture
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161765
         File1299725479.jpg-(28 KB, 327x299, 1294246996786.jpg)
    28 KB
    >>24161714
    >> MegaSweet !6/JhxoKXsc 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161769
         File1299725485.jpg-(15 KB, 269x279, scoot yawn.jpg)
    15 KB
    >>24161714

    Awesome!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161770
    >>24161695
    If you want to make one then join the current general and ask to make the next, or give suggestions as to what the next topic should be. We can't have bronies making threads just because they don't see it on the front page.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161771
    http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=C82444B2718E0B84

    CONFOUND THESE PONIES, THEY WILL RUIN MY PROFILE
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:51 No.24161786
         File1299725517.png-(128 KB, 800x800, Filly Trixie.png)
    128 KB
    >>24161742
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:52 No.24161793
         File1299725526.jpg-(827 KB, 2048x1120, Fluttershystudying.jpg)
    827 KB
    New drawfag here. I am fairly new to drawing, but I thought I might contribute.

    Fluttershy studying?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:52 No.24161799
         File1299725533.png-(184 KB, 1041x780, My god, it's full of derp!.png)
    184 KB
    >> Rainbro Cash !!ZEHMsOUkeax 03/09/11(Wed)21:52 No.24161803
         File1299725537.png-(291 KB, 635x649, 1298756126712.png)
    291 KB
    Need some feedback on my fanfic concept...

    Twilight and friends are off to Canterlot for a dubtrot(lol) concert..

    Story is written from the POV of two Canterlot colts who are following the fillies.

    Obvious shipping.... Male characters introduced...

    Don't know whether to keep it tasteful, go ridiculously dirty, or abandon the concept entirely...

    Wat do bronies?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:52 No.24161814
    >>24161710
    At first, I thought RD was licking the glass cover of the helmet.

    Also, I didn't really like Twilight at the beginning. Taught by the God-Princess of Ponykind, and her special talent was Magic, I thought they were better off calling her Mary Sue. But then she just keeps getting beat up as the show goes on. I feel sorry for her now.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:53 No.24161837
    >>24161714
    Oh god your voice is beautiful, it’s a shame the quality of your microphone though
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:53 No.24161840
         File1299725613.png-(85 KB, 867x599, Rarity.png)
    85 KB
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:53 No.24161844
    >>24161803
    Keep it clean.

    Also, make sue you actually make the colts three dimensional characters.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:54 No.24161877
    >>24161803

    Original characters, no matter how small their role, is always a slippery slope.

    I'd consider trying to use the same story, without original characters. But if you MUST use them, use them in an observer-only capacity. Avoid having them interact with the main cast if possible.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:55 No.24161899
         File1299725736.jpg-(19 KB, 514x286, pony12.jpg)
    19 KB
    >>24161837
    yeah, it's cheap but it does okayish for now.

    Also thank you.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:56 No.24161919
         File1299725801.png-(432 KB, 609x720, 1299539680795.png)
    432 KB
    >>24161770
    I did. I even screencapped the post waiting to be submitted. I'm all for keeping it to one general. Although I love starting new threads, I guess I'll have to share at some point. Seems like my threads always have something good happen.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:56 No.24161927
         File1299725816.png-(292 KB, 766x563, Fluttershy is not amused.png)
    292 KB
    >>24161628
    HOW IS RAINBOW DASH CONTROLLING THAT ROBOT HAND WITH HOOF
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:57 No.24161936
         File1299725833.png-(111 KB, 894x894, cutie_mark_crusaders____yay_by(...).png)
    111 KB
    I want them to make big plushies of the Cutie Mark Crusaders so I can have the three of them in my bed every night.
    >> Rainbro Cash !!ZEHMsOUkeax 03/09/11(Wed)21:57 No.24161938
         File1299725837.png-(58 KB, 270x269, 1298842882809.png)
    58 KB
    >>24161877

    >>24161844

    Thanks for the feedback. It's going to be tough to build characters from scratch...
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)21:58 No.24161973
         File1299725910.png-(929 KB, 1920x1080, Orange.png)
    929 KB
    Why have I never seen a screenshot of Orange Pinkie?
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)21:59 No.24161990
    >write multi-chapter historical fiction piece with expanded world, battle scenes, political intrigue, and ponies that takes weeks of writing
    >it's ignored
    >write sappy unrequited love story in an afternoon
    >60 comments and an essay
    >such is life in Equestria
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)21:59 No.24161991
         File1299725958.jpg-(253 KB, 1281x914, Rarity_sniping2.jpg)
    253 KB
    Maybe could post some old and forgotten fanart?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:00 No.24162017
    FiM in graphic novel format would just be the bee's knees. I'd like it to be a miniseries which followed each of the ponies before Twilight came to Ponyville. But not too far before, like just a few months. Each issue would just focus on a particular character, where they overcome some dilemma or little adventure, to give kind of a closeup of their personality.
    >> Tanner !ebRxo1tmWU 03/09/11(Wed)22:00 No.24162031
    >>24161990

    I like your stuff Fon Shaolin. But I think the majority of people here don't want to get invested in grand stories like that

    makes me sad
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:00 No.24162034
    >>24161990
    So did you write "A Ponies History of the Dragon War"? Because I LOVED that. It was great.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:01 No.24162047
    >>24161990

    It's a tough life, being the last bastion of good taste in the MLP fandom. But, we must fight the good fight, lest talent and depth vanish from the fanfiction ponyverse with our passing.

    ...Dammit, even I can't tell if I'm being sarcastic or not anymore.
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:01 No.24162052
    >>24161990

    They are fanfics.
    People just want to see what happens in the end.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:02 No.24162073
         File1299726139.jpg-(24 KB, 1048x623, Dibujo.jpg)
    24 KB
    SHADOW THE PONY ORIGINAL CHARACTER DO NOT STEAL
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:02 No.24162083
         File1299726157.png-(953 KB, 1482x850, 1299521021941.png)
    953 KB
    Wait a minute... This was also supposed to be a Trixie thread.

    On topic: Trixie comic, a 'super' pony that stops crime and doesn't afraid of anything!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:02 No.24162087
    >>24161990

    >weeks of writing

    That's why you should NOT invest too much time in a single story
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:02 No.24162093
    >>24162031
    This is rather disconcerting to me, because I'm currently at work on my own grand story. I'd like to think that strong character interaction and the sheer novelty of seeing new places and new ideas presented through the filter of Friendship Is Magic would keep people reading.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:03 No.24162096
    >>24161990
    A friend of mine read it. Wee both agree it was well-done. Sorry you didn't get the recognition.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:05 No.24162157
         File1299726353.png-(295 KB, 1281x914, 1292288079192i.png)
    295 KB
    >>24161991
    I like old art, simply because it's so uncommon
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:05 No.24162161
         File1299726358.jpg-(40 KB, 500x453, 1299624799913.jpg)
    40 KB
    Nobody agrees on Trixie Time
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:06 No.24162172
    >a tripfag whines about not getting enough attention
    >a bunch of Anons start kissing his ass

    ...What the hell is going on here?!
    >> Snowball 03/09/11(Wed)22:06 No.24162177
    you think that Faust will be taking character ideas? Got some good shit but then, there probably a lot of people with good character ideas.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:06 No.24162193
    Anyone got that picture of Twilight with her eyes red and wide open from the parasprite episode?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:06 No.24162195
         File1299726419.png-(220 KB, 611x556, 1299618207759.png)
    220 KB
    OP again. Since my original idea was ignored, let's try this on for size:

    If you could go on ONE adventure with Trixie, what would you wanna do. Try to keep it clean, you gutterminds (you know who you are).
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:07 No.24162205
         File1299726448.png-(63 KB, 160x189, Screen shot 2011-03-09 at 9.05(...).png)
    63 KB
    Mizz Twist, you're trying to seduce me, aren't you?
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:07 No.24162207
         File1299726450.png-(85 KB, 533x325, Picture 125.png)
    85 KB
    I need your voices!

    http://www.ponychan.net/chan/collab/res/245.html
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:07 No.24162208
    >>24162157

    Ooooh, it was colored? Nice!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:07 No.24162212
    >>24162172
    >trying to start tripfag drama
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162223
    >>24162195
    I would help con some podunk country town.
    >> Pimps McGee !!1XJKWa7B+Gb 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162225
         File1299726493.jpg-(408 KB, 945x945, 1299724119232.jpg)
    408 KB
    Man I colored this fast.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162230
    >>24162172

    it sucks when you write a really cool long story and you get nearly no feedback on it.

    I know that feel, and so do other people
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162234
    >>24162172
    Anonymous I love you so much. I dream about you everyday.
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162236
    >>24162172
    Hey, I wasn't whining per-say, I was just commenting that shipping fics are getting a lot more attention than general fics.

    In a way that promotes my own work.

    Anyway, is there a new episode this week or next week?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:08 No.24162253
    >>24162172
    Welcome to mlp
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:09 No.24162259
         File1299726552.jpg-(165 KB, 900x818, 1299118451321.jpg)
    165 KB
    what's everybody's view on tragic villian Trixie? i.e. never got attention as a child because of alcoholic single mother
    Or do you guys prefer the lighter, twilight-crush Trixie?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:09 No.24162265
    >>24161990
    Yeah I spent a fun morning just analysizing episodes, and actually wrote a half-way serious few paragraphs with it. Aside from first learning to rip episodes, it was the most time consuming work I did for ponies.

    Of course it was ignored. But you just gotta change your work till others enjoy it. Unfortunately, it is lack of interest that kills deep stuff, and it seems that work that take an "easy out" get the attention.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:09 No.24162274
         File1299726579.jpg-(183 KB, 710x560, Vinyl_1.jpg)
    183 KB
    Question: are there any Vinyl fanfics? preferably not shipping?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:10 No.24162299
         File1299726637.png-(293 KB, 1281x914, 1292288079192j.png)
    293 KB
    >>24162208
    Well, I colored it. I have so much old stuff.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:10 No.24162301
         File1299726642.png-(141 KB, 572x464, 1299618160841.png)
    141 KB
    >>24162259
    Thanks for posting the better version of that pic
    >> Snowball 03/09/11(Wed)22:10 No.24162306
    i made a charming and vivid character and wish it to become reality.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:10 No.24162307
         File1299726659.jpg-(213 KB, 1280x945, cool-pony.jpg)
    213 KB
    >>24161473
    ponies ARE REAL
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:11 No.24162317
         File1299726682.png-(57 KB, 210x202, not interested.png)
    57 KB
    >>24162274

    Yeah let me just post the lin-

    >without shipping

    Oh, sorry hun... Can't help you there...
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:11 No.24162330
         File1299726705.png-(224 KB, 4877x4500, Bummed.png)
    224 KB
    >>24162301

    Every single time...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:12 No.24162337
    >>24162307

    HOLY SHIT PONIES ARE REAL!? I THOUGHT THAT WAS A BIG DOG

    WHAT HAS SCIENCE DONE
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:12 No.24162345
    >>24162236
    Wait, YOU were the one who wrote the Dragon War fic? The one talking to various pony generals?

    That actually made me want to write a fic based on that concept, except focusing on modern day Spike.

    I really enjoyed that story, so you have 1 reader.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:12 No.24162347
    >>24161990

    While I do know the feeling, I have to say that, above all else, don't take yourself too seriously. Even if you're the Joseph Heller of the MLP fandom nothing is more insufferable than someone who thinks he's all that. Remember you're writing MLP fanfiction bro, and just write for the sake or writing.

    That being said I'm starting on my own fanfic, still in the planning stages. I might post it here when I'm done but I don't expect it to be anytime soon.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:12 No.24162349
    Goddammit ponies quit making me want to write fanfic. Somebody else will just have to write about Luna being in a lesbian love square with a light-hearted, flirty earth pony painter hired to make her portrait, a shy, but tough pegasus guard stuck on the night shift, and her own jealous, possessive sister Princess Celestia
    >> jack !wI9PECpX8g 03/09/11(Wed)22:12 No.24162351
         File1299726772.png-(75 KB, 209x267, 129884045583-flowers_all.png)
    75 KB
    >>24162195
    Having heard of Trixie's great power through the gossip and grapevine, you approach Trixie pleading for her help in defeating a powerful evil/rescuing a loved one.

    Trixie's arrogance does not permit her to admit she's not up to the task and she plays you for a rube, charging a high price for her services while elusively hiding her trepidation about the task ahead. Through challenges and adversity, you and Trixie actually grow to bond, and she even saves your ass a few times; discovering her own magical potential in the process.

    When it is finally time to face the big bad and save the day, Trixie is up to the task and astounds everyone with her newly developed powers. But She couldn't have done it without you. Will she ever admit it ?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:13 No.24162356
    >>24162195
    An adventure with Trixie? How... Magical...

    Anyway, all I would want to do with Trixie is travel from town to town doing magic tricks.

    Like....
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:13 No.24162369
         File1299726826.png-(124 KB, 325x293, 1299485990369.png)
    124 KB
    >>24162356
    Forgot.

    (other image was used)
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:14 No.24162377
    >>24162317
    ill take it if there isnt anything else
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:14 No.24162386
         File1299726876.png-(681 KB, 860x860, 1299576744757.png)
    681 KB
    >>24162330
    Ya know somethin' funny? I'm that guy that said he got too excited when his threads do well.

    I still do...
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:14 No.24162390
         File1299726884.png-(76 KB, 431x404, 1289829699998.png)
    76 KB
    >>24162345
    >>24162034
    No, I didn't write that one.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:15 No.24162400
    >>24162349
    Yeah. I think the fandom is better off if you weren't writing fanfics.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:15 No.24162406
         File1299726925.png-(191 KB, 640x360, 1293034987846.png)
    191 KB
    >>24161990
    I think I saw it before. Unfortunately I can't remember much of it. Mostly I read books not just for the plot and characters. But for the writing style. Shit it could have the worst plot ever devised by human hands but if it's written well I'll barely notice. Good plots can make shitty writing worth it, which is why I read fanfics. But obviously it's a mixture of both that makes it good. Like Charles Dickens. I can tell from the first paragraph he had a blast writing the story. If the writer fucking hated the scene what makes me supposed to like it? Anyway most of the Shipping fics only get responses like "good" or "moar please" which are slightly better then no response at all. Basically here's what I'm saying. Write for yourself first, then write for the public. That's what I do ( I haven't completed a story. EVER. But I enjoy the process.)
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:15 No.24162414
         File1299726944.jpg-(486 KB, 749x2511, ponyhistory5-(n1299691908420).jpg)
    486 KB
    >>24162034

    No, that's somebody else. Here's part 5, by the way.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:15 No.24162417
         File1299726951.jpg-(176 KB, 1342x761, ScreenHunter_01 Mar. 09 22.15.jpg)
    176 KB
    >shit just got real
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:16 No.24162424
    >>24161793
    >>24161793

    Looks nice. I'm not a good art critic, but no one else responded
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:16 No.24162426
    >>24162236

    Personally Fon, I like shipping because I like getting warm fuzzies from reading, and for some reason pony shipping provides lots of warm fuzzies.

    Outside of shipping, I like AU's, but only alternate timelines and Peggy sues.

    Contextual reassignments like A Kingdom for a Horse don't interest me as much. I'm still reading it, mind, but I'm just not enthused with it like I have been with some of your other stuff.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:16 No.24162437
         File1299727003.gif-(49 KB, 290x360, Dude...What.gif)
    49 KB
    >>24162386
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:16 No.24162439
    >>24162195
    ........
    I dream of working part time as a Trixie roadie.
    Are you seriously going to make me choose?
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:16 No.24162441
    >>24162390
    Ha! You wrote "A Kingdom for a Hose"

    Mediocre. The characters in the fic had no reaction to each other and the story is a garbled mess. Sorry.

    If it makes you feel any better I DIDNT read your shipping fics. I hate Rainbow Dash, no offense.
    >> Purple Daze Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:17 No.24162451
         File1299727025.png-(68 KB, 175x291, noway.png)
    68 KB
    Well, while we're on fanfics, I figure I'll post the one I just finished right here then. i'm emailing blog pony right now. I'd appreciate it if you come in and give it a looksee and tell me hwat you liked and didn't like, and if you can help me spot some sneaky grammra mishaps.

    It's a story about Twilight, Dash and Pinkie. Hope you like it

    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TotJMMaMULV-EH11kCBEy5OmynarsgtzZe2zLVU-Fqc/edit?hl=en&authk
    ey=CM_9p6MH#
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:17 No.24162455
    >>24162236
    There is a new episode, right? Rarity centric, I think.

    As for fics - fact is, people like romance. Especially when they're already feeling girlified by cute ponies. Whaddayagonnado?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:17 No.24162469
         File1299727058.png-(46 KB, 192x219, What.png)
    46 KB
    >>24162417
    >Rainbow Dash
    >he
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:18 No.24162476
    >>24162414
    Who wrote this BTW? It really sparked my interest.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:18 No.24162496
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CFpZ86T5Z_Q

    U mad?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:19 No.24162499
         File1299727148.png-(101 KB, 200x233, 1298654270809.png)
    101 KB
    >>24162437
    I said I needed to be taken down a notch so I would stop getting all giddy and you said I'll never amount to anything in my short, pathetic life.

    Anything? Well, at this rate, you may be right....
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:19 No.24162503
    >>24162441
    ...ouch. Tips on improving my writing?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:19 No.24162513
    >>24162476

    Not the author, but I know who it is. He wanted to remain anonymous.
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:20 No.24162521
    >>24162259
    I've always liked the one where her ego is a defense to coping with barely surviving the destruction of hoofington.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:20 No.24162523
    >>24162441

    What?!

    Rainbow Dash is the coolest! Except for Applejack.

    And here I was thinking you and I were just so similar.
    >> writefriend !Jh/WV/yQFw 03/09/11(Wed)22:20 No.24162525
    Writefriend here as my name suggests. Taking requests.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:21 No.24162547
         File1299727268.png-(996 KB, 956x772, Trixie_is_soaking_wet_for_Twil(...).png)
    996 KB
    *tastes thread*

    Needs moar Trixie.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:21 No.24162551
         File1299727276.jpg-(12 KB, 252x238, 1299458079235.jpg)
    12 KB
    >>24162417
    >he
    What? Why did he use a ma-
    >Is romantically involved with "Pinkie Pie"
    OH CELESTIA IT MAKES SENSE NOW
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:21 No.24162564
         File1299727300.png-(191 KB, 1000x800, Human Vinyl.png)
    191 KB
    >>24162525
    normal Vinyl Scratch, since there doesnt seem to be any...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:21 No.24162569
         File1299727313.jpg-(410 KB, 890x788, Rainbow Dash gives Fluttershy (...).jpg)
    410 KB
    >>24162330
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:22 No.24162576
    >>24162503
    I'm a different guy, but when you're writing, have a clear outline of three things:
    1. What you want to happen.
    2. How you want it to happen.
    3. Who it happens to.

    Now, this sounds simpler than it is. It's about fleshing each detail out, why it happens that way, and how exactly the characters interact. You have to really feel the characters, and know what they're thinking at all times, even if you aren't writing with their thoughts available to the reader.
    >> jack !wI9PECpX8g 03/09/11(Wed)22:22 No.24162583
         File1299727342.png-(69 KB, 425x436, 129726541455-Trixie_the_White.png)
    69 KB
    >>24162547
    I AM RUINING THE SOUP.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:22 No.24162596
         File1299727377.png-(94 KB, 800x960, My Little Pony Apple Bloom 2.png)
    94 KB
    >>24162499

    Oh yeah! That guy.

    Sorry, I'm not feelin' the hostility tonight.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:23 No.24162600
         File1299727383.png-(21 KB, 398x341, 1299267329910.png)
    21 KB
    >>24162525
    >>24162547
    Do it, ya know ya wanna shipppppppppppppppp
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)22:24 No.24162633
    >>24161445
    >how much would you pay?
    My money. All of it.
    >> writefriend !Jh/WV/yQFw 03/09/11(Wed)22:24 No.24162641
    >>24162600
    Trixie Twilight ship? Already did it <3
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:24 No.24162645
         File1299727498.png-(159 KB, 374x450, 1299703013241.png)
    159 KB
    >>24162596
    That's ok. Doesn't seem to work anyway.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:25 No.24162648
    >>24162525

    Hm...well, I can't think of anything absolutely outlandish (which are the most fun fics imo), soooooooo...maybe some event narrated by Pinkie Pie in which you can just decipher what's going on but it's muddled by her eccentric ranting, strange analogies, and frequent tangents? Bit of a tall order I know but that's all I can think of right now.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:25 No.24162651
         File1299727507.jpg-(13 KB, 320x241, HNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGG.jpg)
    13 KB
    >>24162569
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:25 No.24162671
    Derpy just sunk your ship.
    What do ?
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:26 No.24162677
         File1299727568.png-(42 KB, 183x158, Picture 63.png)
    42 KB
    >>24162351
    >>24162351
    FUND FUND FUND FUND FUND IT!!!
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:26 No.24162682
         File1299727575.png-(119 KB, 600x583, My Little Pony Fluttershy Rain(...).png)
    119 KB
    >>24162641

    how about a little FlutterDash then?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:27 No.24162712
         File1299727639.png-(80 KB, 329x289, gilda mad.png)
    80 KB
    Are you brave enough to stand in a dark room and say "Gilda" ten times to a mirror?
    >> writefriend !Jh/WV/yQFw 03/09/11(Wed)22:27 No.24162717
    >>24162682
    RainbowShy? Hm...
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:27 No.24162724
         File1299727669.jpg-(19 KB, 188x241, 3793_ddea..jpg)
    19 KB
    >>24162351
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:27 No.24162726
         File1299727671.jpg-(51 KB, 600x375, shutup.jpg)
    51 KB
    >most of this thread
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:27 No.24162727
         File1299727674.png-(135 KB, 375x276, 1299725144914.png)
    135 KB
    I know nothing about the actual show and have never seen an episode but I find myself magically enthralled by the constant influx of pics being posted. The reaction images are fuckin boss.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:28 No.24162732
         File1299727681.png-(154 KB, 600x600, Pinkie Pie marries Rainbow Das(...).png)
    154 KB
    >>24162682
    Silly filly, that's now how you spell PinkieDash!
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)22:28 No.24162742
    >>24162671
    Nothing, I'm fucking drowning.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:28 No.24162747
         File1299727728.png-(125 KB, 278x345, very happy.png)
    125 KB
    >>24162682

    I'd like to second the RainbowShy suggestion!
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:29 No.24162757
         File1299727748.png-(284 KB, 945x945, My Little Pony Fluttershy Rain(...).png)
    284 KB
    >>24162732

    I can spell FlutterDash just fine, thankyouverymuch.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:29 No.24162759
         File1299727764.png-(175 KB, 950x1100, 1299619648977.png)
    175 KB
    OP who feels he overposts in his threads.

    This is my second thread in a row I posted tonight. I started four yesterday, and three the day before. I feel like I'm being greedy, but it seems that every thread I make somehow avoids falling into the usual pitfalls that so plague these threads. This is really bugging me. Should I let someone else make the next thread? I know how it feels to be excluded, and I don't wanna piss anyone with a good general topic off.

    Thoughts, anyone?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:29 No.24162773
         File1299727796.png-(291 KB, 640x360, beard.png)
    291 KB
    >>24162417
    >[s]he has a scratchy voice
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162777
         File1299727804.jpg-(213 KB, 801x481, flockdraw threesomes.jpg)
    213 KB
    why choose?
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162781
         File1299727811.jpg-(307 KB, 660x660, Derpyhuman.jpg)
    307 KB
    >>24162712
    Did it.That was actually pretty scary.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162784
         File1299727821.png-(39 KB, 1543x869, seriouslyknockitoff.png)
    39 KB
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162786
         File1299727824.png-(1.61 MB, 1109x1690, Valentines.png)
    1.61 MB
    >>24162523
    You and I will never be the same I'm afraid.

    By the way I just reread your fic and realized that this is an alternate reality where the group never even came together.

    So fuck me, I just misunderstood basically your whole story.

    So instead of critiquing your writing which actually isn't that bad (sorry for the misunderstanding) I'm just going to tell you why your fic isn't getting recognition.

    1. In this twisted dimension, the friends are split. Splitting up the main cast is a ballsy thing to do, and a lot of people watch this show and read fanfiction STRICTLY for the interactions they have together.

    2. You followed Applejack. Of all of the people you could follow in a war-torn Equestria, you follow the Farming Earth pony. That won't get you any recognition.

    3. The story is a little hard to follow. You throw a TON of stuff at the reader in the introduction, which immediately makes a lot of readers quit. Although it begins to make a bit more sense later, believe me when I say that if you confuse your readers too much in the first few paragraphs, they tuck tail and run.

    I'll continue reading it though. Good luck.

    Rainbow Dash is bad BTW. The fact that 4chan latched onto her should be evidence enough.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162788
    >>24162759

    don't take making new threads so seriously
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:30 No.24162789
         File1299727829.jpg-(100 KB, 700x700, Pinkie pie nibbles Rainbow Das(...).jpg)
    100 KB
    >>24162757
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:31 No.24162803
         File1299727863.png-(103 KB, 500x520, 1293166104509.png)
    103 KB
    >>24162641

    Appledash shipping is best shipping you know.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:31 No.24162810
         File1299727885.jpg-(257 KB, 800x800, My Little Pony Fluttershy Rain(...).jpg)
    257 KB
    >>24162789

    Oh, it's on now.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:31 No.24162823
         File1299727910.jpg-(23 KB, 600x333, 1299557554106.jpg)
    23 KB
    >>24162641
    TrixiexTwilight and you didn't tell me where to find it?!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:32 No.24162830
    Oh yeah, and as far as the comic, art done by Katzeh/FelisOvum
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:32 No.24162838
         File1299727946.png-(300 KB, 750x750, Pinkie Pie riding Gilda while (...).png)
    300 KB
    >>24162810
    Gilda is invited, too. Pinkie likes inviting people to these parties.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:32 No.24162841
    >>24162788
    I know I shouldn't but I have an addictive personality, not to mention OCD like a madman.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:32 No.24162848
         File1299727973.jpg-(13 KB, 251x251, wtf am I reading.jpg)
    13 KB
    >>24162803
    >Fistful of Apples.
    >Favorite ship isn't Big Mac x Applejack

    Pic related.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:33 No.24162854
         File1299727986.png-(427 KB, 750x750, My Little Pony Rainbow Dash Gi(...).png)
    427 KB
    >>24162838

    sure why not
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)22:33 No.24162869
         File1299728018.png-(51 KB, 188x215, uh huh.png)
    51 KB
    dum dee dum dee dum
    Oh hey guys
    what have missed?
    oh more shipping?
    good to know i haven't missed anything
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:33 No.24162871
         File1299728020.jpg-(75 KB, 374x470, 1289608633361.jpg)
    75 KB
    >>24162810
    >>24162803
    >>24162789
    >>24162757
    >>24162732
    >>24162682
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:33 No.24162874
         File1299728025.png-(136 KB, 473x462, fluttershy4536346.png)
    136 KB
    >>24161445
    >how much would you pay?
    i would illegally download it, i have already given hasbro too much of my money on pony toys
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162879
         File1299728042.jpg-(1.53 MB, 1142x1600, Gilda and Rainbow Dash make up.jpg)
    1.53 MB
    >>24162854
    Good end.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162883
         File1299728046.jpg-(35 KB, 500x408, 129923043482.jpg)
    35 KB
    >>24162803

    silly foals, you know deep in your heart this is the only outcome
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162900
         File1299728072.jpg-(81 KB, 500x500, DerpSnail.jpg)
    81 KB
    >>24162784
    No one >cares but you.

    >>24162869
    Yeah, pretty much.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162902
         File1299728076.jpg-(471 KB, 783x790, elementsofharmony.jpg)
    471 KB
    Ok, guys, pony theory time.

    What if the four stars that aided in NMM's escape were in fact not stars, but planets? And, as celestial objects, perhaps they too fall under the dominion of ponies. There are five planets visible with the naked eye (Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn), so what if there are five other pegacorn ponies in the world, off in other places - the precise number of extra bodies required for Celestia to have used the Elements of Harmony.

    They could be rulers in other lands, of other species - Jupiter's "pony", for example, could be ruler/progenitor of the zebras. Mercury could be a gazelle, mars a horse, et cetera. It's not very likely, but I like it for the possibility of some kind of pony world tour string of episodes.

    What say you?
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162909
         File1299728093.png-(194 KB, 660x487, Picture 126.png)
    194 KB
    >>24162671
    Jump up on her back and yell, UP UP AND AWAY, FALCOR!
    >> writefriend !Jh/WV/yQFw 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162911
    So many conflicting rainbowdash type emotions...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:34 No.24162912
         File1299728097.jpg-(42 KB, 358x243, shipping time.jpg)
    42 KB
    >friendly shipping war
    >i am ok with this

    WHAT TIME IS IT?
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:35 No.24162919
         File1299728111.jpg-(339 KB, 945x945, My Little Pony Applejack Rainb(...).jpg)
    339 KB
    >>24162883

    Nonsense!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:35 No.24162921
         File1299728114.jpg-(393 KB, 880x960, 1298692412091.jpg)
    393 KB
    >>24162883
    Fuck your shit.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:35 No.24162937
    >>24162869

    better than cupcakes
    >> Wild Cherry Lollipop caluriri 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162947
         File1299728174.jpg-(167 KB, 945x945, worst_date_ever-color.jpg)
    167 KB
    MS if you still around i want to thank you again for this pic now in color
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162952
    >>24162759
    It's good to take the initiative in making a new general and at least you posted you were going to make the next one (right?)

    If someone else wants to make one they have to speak up. I don't care who starts the thread and I've started a few generals too by asking if someone wanted me to start the next.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162957
         File1299728196.jpg-(114 KB, 678x475, Writing pony.jpg)
    114 KB
    >Shippy Sue was taken
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162959
         File1299728199.png-(361 KB, 3396x2347, gildcud.png)
    361 KB
    warm fuzzies ftw
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162961
    >>24162786

    I probably wouldn't read it if it wasn't following Applejack. Or Rainbow Dash I suppose.

    Because Rainbow Dash is awesome.
    >> jack !wI9PECpX8g 03/09/11(Wed)22:36 No.24162967
         File1299728217.jpg-(Spoiler Image, 119 KB, 766x1043, rarity_is_apples_for_aj_by_hyb(...).jpg)
    Spoiler Image, 119 KB
    Rarity and Applejack for life.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:37 No.24162971
    >>24162947
    >mixing sherbert and chocolate ice cream

    Zebra, you just went full oatmeal.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:37 No.24162972
    >>24162902

    There's a fanfic mythology thing about that. He fleshed out four new characters. Each named after transneptunian objects.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:37 No.24162979
         File1299728250.png-(74 KB, 328x415, Rainbow Dash Pinkie kiss.png)
    74 KB
    >>24162869
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24162992
         File1299728280.gif-(499 KB, 500x335, 1299455320804.gif)
    499 KB
    >>24162869
    >Still on exposition
    Hold on while I beat myself up for the next hour or so.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24162993
         File1299728285.jpg-(10 KB, 138x171, 1299271057379.jpg)
    10 KB
    >>24162902
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24162996
         File1299728288.png-(202 KB, 981x1050, BigMacnLuna.png)
    202 KB
    >>24162947
    i don't know why i like this pairing
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24163008
         File1299728313.png-(213 KB, 640x360, rarity applejack seducing.png)
    213 KB
    >>24162967
    why spoiler that bro?
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24163014
         File1299728318.png-(355 KB, 1250x640, 1299566648382.png)
    355 KB
    >>24162919
    >>24162921

    Calm down my dears... I only say this because I've always been an Apple/Rarity kinda person...

    Here, if I post this picture does it make you feel better?
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)22:38 No.24163017
         File1299728327.png-(48 KB, 256x256, 1296156146982.png)
    48 KB
    >>24162773
    I laughed like a moron at this
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:39 No.24163024
    >>24162947
    .........how did Big Mac levitate Luna's icecream and put it on his?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:39 No.24163047
         File1299728392.png-(105 KB, 507x429, rarity applejack implying frie(...).png)
    105 KB
    >>24163014
    > I only say this because I've always been an Apple/Rarity kinda person...
    AWW YEAH
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163053
    >>24163014
    >0r0ch1
    Since we're too heavy on the pics ITT, ohboyherewego.jpg
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163057
         File1299728409.jpg-(14 KB, 328x261, 1299610368675.jpg)
    14 KB
    >>24162952
    Since yesterday I've started saying I'm gonna post the next thread because I always have an idea. I even screencap the OP so others will actually "see" that I've got it covered. Although, I do take requests for ideas. So I guess it shouldn't bother me too much since others are still getting their ideas heard, albeit through a middleman (me). I also give credit for ideas where credit is due. For example, if you missed the beginning of this thread, my original topic came from a friend on XBL.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163058
    >>24163024
    And now I can never see that image the same way again.
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163070
         File1299728428.png-(22 KB, 417x500, 1298180465927.png)
    22 KB
    >>24162786
    Oh thank god my writing isn't bad. I was seriouslly just about to /wrist.

    And I -like- Applejack. My other stories followed her and got comments hand-over-fist, so I figured there were enough people willing to roll with it.

    As for the group, they're slowly getting back together. It's just going to take a half dozen chapters. Maybe when it gets caught up a few chapters it'll be easier to sit down and digest?

    >shipping war
    >put on my Ranma shipping war face
    >Church of Applejack is go
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163075
    >>24162961
    Your also probably the biggest Applejack fan in the fandom.

    Maybe SeargentSprinkles beats you. Dunno. Do you ship yourself with Applejack?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:40 No.24163080
         File1299728449.jpg-(58 KB, 1000x660, applexmac.jpg)
    58 KB
    >>24162869
    That's just because you're not seeing any applemac
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:41 No.24163090
         File1299728462.png-(294 KB, 497x795, 1296446106857.png)
    294 KB
    >>24162947
    ahhh shit i didnt know that was supposed to be luna i thought it was fluttershy
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:41 No.24163096
         File1299728471.jpg-(136 KB, 608x475, buttershy.jpg)
    136 KB
    Someone /r/'d this a while ago.

    I must be damn slow, only when making this file name did I realize fluttershy is a pun on butterfly.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:41 No.24163100
    >>24162848

    Yeah you're right, Applemac is my favourite ship.

    But I didn't want to request Applemac, I wanted to request Appledash.

    I try to lay off the Applemac sometimes.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:41 No.24163105
         File1299728490.png-(95 KB, 334x377, checkem.png)
    95 KB
    New MLP:FiM musical mash-up. Check it out.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDynYwhUyoY
    >> Klondike 03/09/11(Wed)22:41 No.24163112
         File1299728503.gif-(1.45 MB, 248x244, 1299583072153.gif)
    1.45 MB
    >>24163014
    >Rainbow Dash
    >The woman of the relationship
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:42 No.24163127
         File1299728534.jpg-(73 KB, 413x357, derpy chan.jpg)
    73 KB
    >>24163024
    THAT EXPLAINS EVERYTHING
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)22:42 No.24163137
         File1299728559.jpg-(7 KB, 183x195, 1299007008155.jpg)
    7 KB
    >>24162992
    i'm saving that gif
    i love John Goodman
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:43 No.24163158
    >>24163096
    Actually, it was the in the last thread. So good timing.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:43 No.24163176
         File1299728613.png-(523 KB, 1100x903, 129958181441-PURPLE-fixd.png)
    523 KB
    >>24163047

    Sigh... You have anymore Apple/Rarity? It'd be nice to have some more... I guess I'll post Ponynetta...
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:44 No.24163191
         File1299728648.png-(113 KB, 600x667, 1299649923443.png)
    113 KB
    >>24163176

    Clearly, I posted the wrong picture!
    >> Gilda's Fury !kmfdmRX7.c 03/09/11(Wed)22:44 No.24163201
         File1299728669.png-(8 KB, 251x251, gilda doubles.png)
    8 KB
    >>24163105
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:44 No.24163204
         File1299728682.png-(67 KB, 600x600, rainbow dash pinkie pie weddin(...).png)
    67 KB
    >>24163112
    0r0ch1 RIPPED IT OFF
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:44 No.24163210
    Did it >work?
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:45 No.24163216
         File1299728711.jpg-(117 KB, 953x497, Spike Rarity2.jpg)
    117 KB
    >>24163070
    They got comments because they involved getting shipped with Rainbow Dash.

    If you want comments, keep writing Rainbow Dash shipping fics.

    I mean for fucks sake one of the most highly commented fics on the sight is RD being shipped with a character that appeared for 2 seconds in the show.

    Welcome to the fandom. It doesn't matter how good of a writer you are.

    1. Is it shipping? +comments
    2. Does it have Rainbow Dash? Hold on to your butts.

    Take A Long Time Coming for example. A pretty poorly written shipping fic, it still got me to be one of the highest commented fics on the site.

    At first I thought I was a god. Then I just realized you either ship or only get a handful of viewers.

    Tough luck.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:45 No.24163223
    Has anyone wrote a 3 way fic yet?

    Because I am
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:45 No.24163225
         File1299728734.png-(43 KB, 800x600, rarity applejack tsun tsun.png)
    43 KB
    >>24163176
    sure do
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:47 No.24163255
         File1299728820.jpg-(280 KB, 945x945, rarity applejack ah wish ah kn(...).jpg)
    280 KB
    >>24163225
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:47 No.24163257
    >>24163210
    Depends on what you were trying.
    Did it?
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:47 No.24163258
         File1299728832.png-(287 KB, 540x411, Picture 127.png)
    287 KB
    >>24162967
    After Swarm of the century, I'm really curious to how Rarity X Dash would turn out.

    Rainbow dash impatiently struggles through the whole thing and forces Rarity to start dominating so they can do things properly
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:47 No.24163273
         File1299728855.jpg-(74 KB, 1000x858, 1299709541423.jpg)
    74 KB
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:48 No.24163286
    >>24163137
    Oh it's Sprinkles.

    I just wanted to say, you wrote my favorite shipping fic without even meaning to make it a ship.

    Didn't really connect with Cupcakes though, as much as I dislike Rainbow Dash.
    >> Hiro !J02Ujjg4Nw 03/09/11(Wed)22:48 No.24163288
         File1299728886.jpg-(130 KB, 600x600, My Little Pony Applejack Rarit(...).jpg)
    130 KB
    >>24163255
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:48 No.24163296
         File1299728909.png-(107 KB, 310x305, eye twinkle.png)
    107 KB
    >>24163258

    Oh! That's an interesting thought... If only I had some talent in field of writing...
    >> The /co/mrade Hunter 03/09/11(Wed)22:48 No.24163298
    >>24161445
    ha. I admit, I chuckled when I saw this.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:49 No.24163304
         File1299728940.jpg-(83 KB, 500x500, 1299566445024.jpg)
    83 KB
    >>24163057
    >>24162759
    Friendly neighborhood OP here.

    After having given it a little thought, I've decided to discard these earlier posts, man the fuck up, blast Dream Theater, and POST PONIES.
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)22:49 No.24163327
         File1299728985.png-(85 KB, 556x615, 1298752952311.png)
    85 KB
    I like you, Water Moccasin.
    I don't like Dash either.
    I do like AJ and her siblings, more than I should
    also, if anyone does ask me, i don't like shipping, mostly because now it's almost anyone ever writes
    however
    I do have a soft for DashMac
    and maybe GildaMac
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:50 No.24163332
         File1299729007.png-(677 KB, 640x360, shot0001.png)
    677 KB
    I never realized how cute TS/AJ were together
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:50 No.24163348
         File1299729046.jpg-(27 KB, 500x500, Bbacon.jpg)
    27 KB
    >>24163327
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:50 No.24163351
         File1299729056.jpg-(126 KB, 489x410, Applejack is impressed by Pink(...).jpg)
    126 KB
    >>24163105
    Nice try.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:51 No.24163356
         File1299729068.png-(49 KB, 600x400, 1299567807790.png)
    49 KB
    >>24163057
    And I'm the general image holder :P

    I'm just trying to keep the ponies on /co/ civilized and it's people like you adding structure to the general threads that keeps us away from all the trolling.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:51 No.24163363
         File1299729098.jpg-(60 KB, 1000x660, gasp.jpg)
    60 KB
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:51 No.24163370
         File1299729109.gif-(15 KB, 550x400, nopetwi.gif)
    15 KB
    >>24163351
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163374
    requesting pic of all the ponies begging Big Mac for a dose of his studly seed
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163376
    >>24163327

    Is that why you KILLED HER!?!?!?

    But seriously, there must be a lot of Dash haters, she seems to die a lot.
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163378
    >>24163216
    Yeah, A Long Time Coming does have a lot of comments. The only ones I can think of that has more would be Forever is Forever, Everyp0ny Loves Dash, and that Trixy fic.

    So, that's one with Applejack as the main character, one with Trixy, and one with Spike. That's not a bad spread.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163387
    >>24163327
    Yeah. Really the only reason I wrote A Long Time Coming was because I realized no one was going to do a Spike x Rarity despite it being (halfway) in the show.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163393
    Hello!
    i'm back! not that anyone cares...
    Has caluriri finished the Sev/Twilight pic?
    >> (゚ 3゚)Onsokumaru !!f6Tejk6TlLT 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163397
         File1299729171.png-(123 KB, 302x303, 38.png)
    123 KB
    >About to re-watch Boast Busters
    >Remember Snips and Snails are in it
    >Re-watch applebuck season instead
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:52 No.24163398
         File1299729174.jpg-(34 KB, 484x270, 1299566288813.jpg)
    34 KB
    >>24163356
    See me here
    >>24163304
    If you want, we can start the next thread when that time comes.
    >> Wild Cherry Lollipop caluriri 03/09/11(Wed)22:54 No.24163435
    >>24162971
    realy is grape ice cream
    >>24162996
    same here also my first fic is based in them
    >>24163024
    Luna´s ice cream just fall off
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:54 No.24163440
    >>24163378
    Whats more frustrating is people coming into my other stories telling me "this fic is good, but it's not A Long Time Coming good".

    Fuck them. Seriously. Try something other than shipping and they ditch you.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:56 No.24163476
    >OP checking Archive Index
    >220 replies/140 images

    What the hell? That can't be too good. Do we need to come up with a new general topic for me to post already?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:56 No.24163480
         File1299729392.png-(600 KB, 1307x1782, rainbow dash pinkie kissu.png)
    600 KB
    >>24163376
    slowpony
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:56 No.24163488
    >>24163398
    We're blasting through these images though. Lets not start another until at least 300+ posts.

    And you can post ponies as long as you're nice about it. And I'm confused as to why you discard those posts.

    confluttershy.jpg
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)22:56 No.24163497
         File1299729417.jpg-(68 KB, 620x800, a4f71d81157a34a74f2ff9b083ee9c(...).jpg)
    68 KB
    >>24163273
    from the thumbnail
    i thought it was the mayor
    kinda wish it was
    i think we need to round out Big M ships with the Mayor and Zecora
    or they're notches on his bedpost


    btw, i think cupcakes may the most comments on EQD
    but i don't like tooting my own horn
    it's too pretentious
    >> TX2 03/09/11(Wed)22:57 No.24163506
    >>24163296
    >>24163296
    It's getting harder to write now that there are so many fics already out there and I've only read a handful of them. There's always the risk of accidently completely paralleling another persons story now.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)22:57 No.24163516
    >>24163387

    You know what, the only reason Forever is Forever has as many comments as it does is because of me.

    I was the first person who had a conflicting opinion with everybody else, and half those comments are me arguing my points with other people.

    Another thing you don't take into account is that updates create more comments. Fics that have chapters get comments each update, while one-shots will only get the one influx of comments.

    That one especially probably has more to do with getting comments than...Rainbow Dash.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)22:57 No.24163520
    >>24163488
    >those posts: whiny blabbering
    >post discarding them: I grew a pair
    >> !J8wKEZOcc2 03/09/11(Wed)22:57 No.24163521
    >>24162648
    > ..maybe some event narrated by Pinkie Pie

    Perfect timing: "My Absolute Mostest Horriblest Day EVER!"

    http://cartoon.adultfanfiction.net/story.php?no=600093036

    grimdark, adult++, bad touch (since the other words trip the post filter, which means not for people who haven't been alive a certain number of years)
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)22:58 No.24163535
    >>24163497
    Cupcakes was the inevitable anomaly.

    The only question was who was going to write it, and how well would it be written?

    You did quite well on the latter part I must admit.
    >> Fon Shaolin !QaHT6HayjI 03/09/11(Wed)22:59 No.24163559
    >>24163506
    Welcome to fan fiction. At a certain point, ideas hit a critical mass and the circle of recycling starts. I mean, just look at all the fucking high school fics there are in other fandoms. Everything is a repost of a repost of a repost...

    Then again, that encourages people to really think outside the box and you get the real gems.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)22:59 No.24163566
    >>24163506

    Well, considering there has been so few episodes, it's inevitable that there will be SOME parallels... But I don't think that should keep anyone from writing! As long as it obviously wasn't copied word for word, people aren't going to care too much are they?
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)22:59 No.24163574
         File1299729584.jpg-(22 KB, 500x500, 1299117744162.jpg)
    22 KB
    >>24163397
    >About to watch Boast Buster's
    >Remember that it's Boast Buster's
    >Watch a better episode
    >mfw I have 17 to choose from.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:00 No.24163585
    >>24163559

    WHICH AREN'T REALLY NOTICED IF THERES NO SHIPPING AM I RIGHT?
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)23:00 No.24163586
    >>24163480

    Guess so.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:00 No.24163610
    >>24162879
    I HATE Gilda. But that Dash! HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGH!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:01 No.24163613
         File1299729662.png-(251 KB, 500x315, tumblr_lhieulloQQ1qc16h3o1_500.png)
    251 KB
    Am I the last person on the planet who still doesn't see any of the ponies together? Not that I have anything against it or anything but Rainbow Dash is too busy being FUCKING AWESOME
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:01 No.24163633
         File1299729709.png-(Spoiler Image, 313 KB, 600x653, 1299029506162.png)
    Spoiler Image, 313 KB
    OK, got a new thread ready to go.

    When we hit image limit, I'ma post the new thread.

    Spoiler to get your attention
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:02 No.24163660
    >>24163633

    When we're at 250 posts?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:03 No.24163672
         File1299729787.png-(243 KB, 499x360, gilda has conflicted feelings.png)
    243 KB
    >>24163610
    I love Gilda, and I love Dash

    But I prefer Gilda and Pinkie as a couple
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:03 No.24163679
    >>24163633

    no you fucknut

    Not yet
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:03 No.24163681
    >Image limit it LOOOOOONG before bump limit.
    We're really, really, REALLY fucking sorry, /co/.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:03 No.24163693
    >>24163660

    Image limit is only a couple posts away.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:04 No.24163711
    >>24163693

    That's not a fucking excuse to go and make a new general so soon
    >> Gray Blob !1fuckupmdM 03/09/11(Wed)23:04 No.24163715
         File1299729884.jpg-(108 KB, 976x1200, 1299168257229.jpg)
    108 KB
    >finally decide to see what all the MLP: FIM hype is all about
    >watch a few episodes
    >no cathartic reaction
    >one day later
    >listening to 1-Speed Bike (Aidan Girt of GY!BE)'s debut album on the bus home
    >track 7, near the end
    >recording of a phone message left by him to an unknown party
    >mfw he starts rambling about My Little Pony
    >mfw at that very moment, I spot a small, heavily rainbow-tinted cloud in the sky
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:04 No.24163716
    >>24163660
    Do YOU wanna go 150 posts without images?

    This isn't a common occurrence so don't look too deep into it.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:05 No.24163733
    My feelings for shipping are the same for, oddly enough, smoking weed. I enjoy weed, I like talking about weed, an if I do a drug, it's sure as shit going to be weed. But I don't talk about it with people that don't enjoy it, I don't feel that everything should be about it, nor will I shit on somebody that doesn't enjoy it.

    I read fanfic primarily for shipping, but that isn't all it can, or should, be about.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:05 No.24163737
    >>24163585

    >people not interested in a fanfic unless it has shipping

    Seems to be the opposite here on /co/... I don't think I've seen a good shipping fic posted here in a while... Heck, the only fanfic in this thread is about smoking weed...
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:05 No.24163753
    >>24163613
    PinkieDash is by far the most confusing ship to me and is actually one of the main reasons I wrote A Long Time Coming.

    In "Griffon the Brush Off". Rainbow Dash actually DISLIKES Pinkie Pie for how annoying she is.

    The only reason she does a quick day of hanging out is to do a few pranks. After that she ditches Pinkie for Gilda, until she does some weird 180 at the end of the episode.

    PinkieDash enrages me.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:06 No.24163771
    >About to re-watch Applebuck season
    >Remember it's all about Applejack
    >Re-watch Boast Busters instead
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:06 No.24163775
    >>24163737

    Oh you read it? What'd you think of it?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:08 No.24163820
    >>24163771

    I'd have a similar experience with most episodes, but that would just make me watch Sonic Rainboom over and over and over again.

    Hmm, actually, that's not a bad idea.
    >> Wild Cherry Lollipop caluriri 03/09/11(Wed)23:08 No.24163835
    >>24163393
    yep i post it early here>>24158880
    hope you like
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:09 No.24163842
    >>24163520
    But I liked the caring OP
    >sadface.jpg
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:10 No.24163887
         File1299730231.jpg-(127 KB, 499x480, 1299472555891.jpg)
    127 KB
    I hope this doesn't turn into a shipping war...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:10 No.24163893
         File1299730250.jpg-(45 KB, 590x350, Rainbow Dash Pinkie's twitchy (...).jpg)
    45 KB
    >>24163753
    she stated that she thought that she was annoying, but then starts liking her.

    >After that she ditches Pinkie for Gilda
    You know, a long lost friends come to visit, you decide to spend the day with them.

    You can always hang out tomorrow with your local friend
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:10 No.24163894
    >>24163775

    I thought it was pretty funny! A little weird that Pinkie Pie get's LESS hyper when she smokes, but someone had to be the straight-man with Twilight out of the picture...

    I also now require a picture of Rainbowdash sleeping surronded by popcorn, cotton candy, and cheese!
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:10 No.24163897
    i don't mean to bitch, but when i go Equestria Daily and see that last 10 uploads, give or take, are all shipping, i start wonder if anyone has the skill to think outside the box.
    is this really all the fans can think of?
    is that all they care about?
    get yer hands out of your pants, people.
    there's a whole world of story potential and you're spending it on soap opera plots.
    but whatever
    i can't stop you
    i'm just gonna write my own ideas
    >> Gilda's Fury !kmfdmRX7.c 03/09/11(Wed)23:11 No.24163899
         File1299730260.jpg-(19 KB, 435x377, applejack stare.jpg)
    19 KB
    >>24163771
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:11 No.24163915
    >>24163842
    I still care, it's just more of a tough love kinda caring.
    >> Tanner !ebRxo1tmWU 03/09/11(Wed)23:12 No.24163940
    >>24163894

    Oh I'm so glad someone like it! This was my first shot at writing something funny too
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)23:12 No.24163942
    >>24163753

    She never dislikes Pinkie, that's reading things that aren't there. Dash thinks Pinkie can be annoying, and doesn't want to be around her all the time.

    When Dash discovered Pinkie liked pranking, she found something else they could do together that wouldn't get on her nerves.

    Dash also never "ditches" Pinkie. Dash, as I've argued before, seems to have the tendency to defer judgement to others. She seems to be easily swayed and manipulated, and that's all that was happening with Gilda. Gilda didn't want to hang out with Pinkie, and Gilda kept bringing things up to distract Dash.

    Probably, Dash didn't have a strong opinion either way on who was more fun to hang out with.

    Come on, don't we all have that friend who we can only handle in small doses? They're still friends, and we like them, but they can get annoying.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163953
    Anyone as confused as me about Rarity having a nice dress in Suited for Success, but in Sonic Rainboom she has that super fruity over the top dress?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163960
    >>24163835
    Thanks Caluriri!
    i loved it!
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163967
    >>about to watch Applebuck Season
    >>realize it's about Applejack
    >>clop clop clop
    >>realize Big Mac's in it
    >>clop clop clop
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163972
    OP here. Launching new thread in FIVE MINUTES.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163981
    >>24163897

    Well hun, no one is trying to prevent you from writing them are they? I must admit that even though I'm in it mostly for the shipping, I do enjoy your work as well... I mean, not Cupcakes so much, but that's probably because it wasn't really my thing...
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:13 No.24163984
    >>24163942
    >And doesn't want to be around her all the time

    Yep.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:14 No.24164000
    >>24163972
    Wait till this one starts autosaging, retard.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:14 No.24164012
    >>24163915
    You're confusing me, but I'll follow you as long as you keep this civil.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:14 No.24164014
    >>24163972

    DON'T YOU DO IT YOU FAGGOT

    DON'T YOU REMEMBER WHAT HAPPENED?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:14 No.24164022
    >>24163897
    Whelp I'm writing three/four fics at once. Only one of them is going to survive I know that. No one has done anything similar to it that I know of. And none are shipping. So why am I writing? Mostly for myself. I write to entertain myself. If someone else enjoys it then that's just doubleplusgood.

    In other news Beating yourself up while listening to Animal Crossing music is a strange experience.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:15 No.24164028
    >>24162451
    Loved it!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:15 No.24164034
    Episode #: Title: Rating:
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Ep. 1: Friendship is Magic: Part 1 ***
    Ep. 2: Friendship is Magic: Part 2 ****
    Ep. 3: Ticket Master ****
    Ep. 4: Applebuck Season ****
    Ep. 5: Griffon the Brush-Off *****
    Ep. 6: Boast Busters ****
    Ep. 7: Dragonshy *****
    Ep. 8: Look Before You Sleep ***
    Ep. 9: Bridle Gossip *****
    Ep. 10: Swarm of the Century ****
    Ep. 11: Winter Wrap-Up *****
    Ep. 12: Call of the Cutie **
    Ep. 13: Fall Weather Friends ****
    Ep. 14: Suited For Success ***
    Ep. 15: Feeling Pinkie Keen ***
    Ep. 16: Sonic Rainboom *****
    Ep. 17: Stare Master **
    Ep: 18: Show Stoppers *
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:15 No.24164038
    >>24163967
    Sprinkles I've never heard of why you like the Apple family so much anyways.

    Don't get me wrong, I like all of them as well, and Applejack is definitely one of my top ponies, but I mean dud...

    you are OBSESSED.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:15 No.24164051
    >>24164000
    Is that 300+ posts and 150 images? If so I will wait.

    asshole
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:15 No.24164060
    >>24163897
    I tried to get my death metal version of evil enchantress on there, but it seems to have been ignored. Oh well
    >> Tanner !ebRxo1tmWU 03/09/11(Wed)23:16 No.24164066
    >>24164028

    Thanks! Glad you loved it!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:16 No.24164068
    >>24163953
    The magic affected her brain
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:16 No.24164082
    >>24163737

    Where is this fanfic? I can't seem to find it.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:16 No.24164091
         File1299730619.gif-(678 KB, 330x190, DJ Vinyl Scratch.gif)
    678 KB
    >>24163715
    >give the song a try
    >the most pretencious song I have listen in a long while

    I recomend daily doses of this
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atnSTtiWU5E&feature=related
    >> BrotherPrickle !381c/kZCq6 03/09/11(Wed)23:17 No.24164096
    >>24163984
    I think the reason they are paired together rests on how they bonded as close friends over pranking, and the ensuing plot about Gilda trying to take Dash away from Pinkie.
    It's more explicitly there than most other potential pairings, at least. Plus, both girls are full of energy, so they should, in theory, be fun to write for.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:17 No.24164107
    >>24163897
    I actually don't view shipping as a sexual thing. I don't get off on it. I just think the idea of certain characters being in love with each other is sweet.

    I dunno, maybe it's because I'm bisexual, but I can see the compatibility between a lot of different characters, regardless of their gender, and I find it sweet.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:17 No.24164111
    >>24164034
    Opinion Rating
    mine *****
    yours*
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:17 No.24164113
    >>24164034
    >FiM part 2 -----> 4 stars
    No. Terribly rushed.

    >Sonic Rainboom ------> 5 stars
    No. No Spike and once again decides to make the male characters complete retards for no reason. Also an attempt to whitewash Rainbow Dash.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164130
    >>24164012
    >>24164000
    WELL THEN TELL THE ANONS TO NOT POST SO MANY DAMN PICTURES.

    AND TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164137
    >>24163953
    Ahh, Rarity assembles her outfits based on what suits the situation! In this case, her ridiculous butterfly wings were crazy and colourful, so they called for Mardi Gras / Carnivale / Cabaret ridiculosity.

    Also it was funnier that she was so silly looking.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164151
    >>24164082

    It's right here, darling!

    >>24162451

    I also just noticed there IS another fanfic in this thread...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164153
    >>24164113
    >No Spike
    I don't see a problem with this
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164154
    >>24163894
    >A little weird that Pinkie Pie get's LESS hyper when she smokes, but someone had to be the straight-man with Twilight out of the picture
    You've never smoked weed before, have you?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:18 No.24164159
    >>24164034
    Good for you
    >> APPLE !JACK2L7aos 03/09/11(Wed)23:19 No.24164165
    >>24164034
    you dont think suited for success it a 5 star for the song?!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:19 No.24164168
    >>24164034
    Suited for Success only 3 stars?

    Nigga you best be foolin
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)23:19 No.24164190
    >>24164034
    >Boast Busters higher than Suited for Success.
    All of my nope.jpg

    >>24164113
    >Also an attempt to whitewash Rainbow Dash.
    I think you meant to say "an attempt to save Rainbow Dash for the bottom".
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:20 No.24164211
    OP will ask one more time.

    When do we migrate, at 350-ish posts or stick it out to 400?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:20 No.24164226
    I keep wanting to write about Snips, Snails, and Spike when their older. With Snips being a successful, famous barber, Snails a world traveling philosopher/entomologist, and Spike having crazy adventures as a diplomat.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:20 No.24164227
    Cody, if you're here, respond.
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:21 No.24164231
    >>24164154

    Indeed, you got me... Everyone I've been around however seem to get a uncontrollable fit of the giggles like in the fanfic, so I figured that was pretty much what happened to everyone?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:21 No.24164233
    >>24164211

    400

    discussion is usually petering out by then anyways
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:21 No.24164250
    >>24164153
    Well then you have poor taste. I'm sorry I can't help you any further.
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)23:22 No.24164267
    >>24164190
    *from the bottom
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:22 No.24164271
    >>24163894
    >A little weird that Pinkie Pie get's LESS hyper when she smokes
    Dude, if you smoke weed and get hyper, then find the creep who put shit in your weed. Weed only calms you down man. Shit, I can't wait till Friday. I'm gonna hit my dealer up, smoke some weed, and watch some ponies.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:22 No.24164286
    >>24164226
    I would read the SHIT out of that.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:22 No.24164287
    >>24164250
    >opinions
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:23 No.24164326
    >>24164231
    Nah bro, Everything goes in slow motion, it's very mellowing. Unless it goes bad, then everything spins very fast.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:23 No.24164327
    >>24164271
    Order a pizza too.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164338
    >>24164287
    I won't stop you from denying the truth. It's ok to be wrong here. You're on 4chan.
    >> Tanner !ebRxo1tmWU 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164341
    >>24164231

    nah, it affects people differently, sometimes extra-ordinary different sometimes.

    I knew a friend who would get horribly depressed from smoking, and eventually had to stop
    >> Lucid !0oSwOEGDeI 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164343
    >>24162947
    Aw man, you beat me to it long time ago.

    I'll post my version next thread.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164346
    >>24164113

    Why don't you like Rainbow Dash? Seems to me you're biased due to factors unrelated to the character, given your word choices here.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164349
    >>24164211
    >>24164233
    I would say it depends on the thread. For this one it might be better to make a new one at 350ish. Nothing under 300 though at LEAST.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164362
    >>24164060
    DUDE post it

    Also do death metal Art of the Dress
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:24 No.24164369
    I actually don't get why Spike gets so much love

    His voice is annoying and the character himself is a bit annoying...
    >> Gilda's Fury !kmfdmRX7.c 03/09/11(Wed)23:25 No.24164381
    >>24164113 whitewash Rainbow Dash
    Explain?

    Are you talking about the "sorry boys, I got plans" line at the end?
    >> FanficPony 03/09/11(Wed)23:25 No.24164404
    >>24164271
    >>24164326

    Oh! How interesting! I must say, what interesting things you can learn in Pony threads!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:26 No.24164409
    >>24164327
    Aww yeeeeee
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:26 No.24164410
    >>24164346
    because he has "better tastes"
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164438
    Ever-present OP here. Watching hyper index like a hawk. If it takes a long time to get to 350-ish I'm gonna post the new thread. Image marker guy be ready.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164443
    >>24164326

    Dash=giggly and silly
    Pinkie=mellowed out
    Twilight-giggly and silly, also a unicorn so shit got real

    I like it
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164449
    >>24164362
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1bGmzSyiiw&feature=channel_video_title
    Funny you should request death metal art of the dress, I actually have been working on and off on a metal instrumental version of that song. It's currently on hold.
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164450
    why does everyone like Bridle Gossip so much?
    it's my least liked episode behind Griffin
    And i can explain my Apple lust
    but later
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164459
    toomanyrulesnotenoughnaptime
    toomanyrulesnotenoughnaptime

    Someone kill my ears that song is amazing!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:27 No.24164460
    >>24164369
    He's cute, he gets a lot of funny lines, and he's a fun character.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:28 No.24164482
    >>24164346
    I will agree that I probably hate her more than I should. Let me tell you why.

    This fandom will not stop talking about her. She has by FAR the most stories, is shipped with EVERYONE, and why?

    Humor? No, she isn't funny.

    Personality? What, being a jerk to her friends more often than being "loyal"?

    It baffles me.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:28 No.24164489
    >>24164404
    The moar you know!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:28 No.24164495
    >>24164450
    i think bridle gossip was pretty meh.
    imo, the only good part was flutterguy.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:28 No.24164497
    >>24164338
    alright
    whatever makes you feel better
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:28 No.24164503
    >>24164450
    Cause it's funny. Especially Flutterguy.

    Also pony racism.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:29 No.24164520
    >>24164438

    Relax bro. You don't have to start the next thread. There will be other threads.

    Grab a glass of water and take things in stride.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:29 No.24164522
    >>24164327
    Order a bacon, pepperoni, and meatball pizza. The first time I did that high I almost cried it was so good.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:29 No.24164523
    where is this story about weed smoking?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:30 No.24164541
    >>24164482
    Cuz Dash is a lesbo and so hawt.

    Besides, any shipfic with her in it is automatically 20% cooler.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:30 No.24164556
    >>24164523

    It's on the ED blog

    Also somewhere on the top of the thread
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:30 No.24164562
    >>24164522
    DUDE. THAT'S WHAT I GET EVERYTIME I ORDER A PIZZA.

    areyouawizard.jpg
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:31 No.24164568
    >>24164520
    I am calm. I just have a good topic. Besides, if you were here earlier, I discovered my threads usually are really good.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:31 No.24164573
    >>24164482
    wait
    are you a contributor

    or you're the guy who bitched in the other thread about spike getting no attention and how liking luna and derpy was bad?


    finally I can filter you
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:31 No.24164575
    >>24164449
    Ah, I see it in the sidebar
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:31 No.24164586
    >>24164541
    There ya go.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:32 No.24164596
    >>24164460
    He's not "cute", but those last two are debatable, I guess
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:32 No.24164602
    I want to see a story about sea bronies.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:32 No.24164615
    >>24164568
    Let's just say I post threads for YOUR benefit.

    That totally makes cents
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:33 No.24164630
    >>24164596
    How is he not cute?
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:33 No.24164636
    >>24164573
    Actually no. I wasn't.

    But I will agree with whoever said it. Luna and Derpy are basically fan characters right now.

    But you've probably already filtered me, which is good. Trying to argue with people who just run away from conversations never works anyways.

    Have fun. Ignorance is bliss after all right?
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:33 No.24164646
    >>24164562
    Yes. Yes I am
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:33 No.24164659
    >>24164541
    Totally true, and well-stated.
    Damn I love her so much.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:34 No.24164665
    >>24164630
    How is he cute?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:34 No.24164684
    >>24164615
    At least he isn't making threads that derail, like those idiots that have "Thread will probably derail anyway" in the OP or some other troll bait sorta thing.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:34 No.24164689
    OP once more. Any guesses as to the next topic?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:35 No.24164696
    >>24164636
    derpy and luna are still awesome though
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:35 No.24164702
    >>24164596
    >opinions
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:35 No.24164715
    >>24164689
    Does it include Luna?

    Hey a game of 20 questions will get us to 400 posts easily! >And I am being 100% serious.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:35 No.24164724
    Might as well use this as the next general since someone just bumped it
    >>24161324
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:36 No.24164732
    >>24164450
    I don't like it either, but it's got good Applebloom. I thought you liked it
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:36 No.24164736
    >>24164684
    >mfw you quoted me to (I think me)
    >mfw I've done the whole "thread's gonna derail anyways" and it was good
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:36 No.24164738
    >>24164636
    Ok see you never!
    I'll continue to enjoy life and these threads will now have 5% less hate and namefaggotry.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:36 No.24164754
    >>24164724
    alright CHANGING PLACES
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >>24161324
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:37 No.24164764
    >>24164724
    Nah, mine's gonna be better.
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:37 No.24164767
    Dash is in every episode, except Sonic Rainboom, is a dickweed
    maybe not so much in Griffin, seeing how she was just there to set up Gilda as an antagonist, and Call of the Cutie where she's just used for comedy, but go watch Ticket Master
    AJ: I wanna Fix Granny and the farm, may I have the ticket?
    RD: I'm selfish and am in it for me. GIMMIE THE TICKET!
    she also almost got everyone killed by a dragon
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:37 No.24164789
    >>24164738
    Oh the name? I only use it when discussing any of the stories I wrote. Guess I forgot to take it off after I got done talking to Fon. Thanks for reminding me.

    No, you'll see me more in the future friend. You just won't know it's me.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164801
    >>24164767
    boy do I love hating characters

    it spreads more friendship and makes less shitsorms
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164808
    >>24164689
    How's this for a freakin topic:

    What was the world like the first time Nightmare Moon rose up, how did society handle her being imprisoned?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164811
    >>24164767
    You really seem to be the only other sane person in this fandom Sprinkles.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164813
    >>24164764
    Too bad. Stop being like "wah I wanna start the new thread."
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164815
    >>24164767
    she's a hotheaded technicolour lesbian
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:38 No.24164820
    >>24164790
    >>24164790
    >>24164790
    >>24164790
    >>24164790
    Well damn. Pick one I guess.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)23:39 No.24164824
    >>24164482

    That's what I figured.

    You know who else this fandom won't stop talking about? Trixie. And Luna. I can't stand either because I'm tired of seeing them being spoken of. So I suppose I understand your position. But I feel I'm a bit more justified than you because Trixie and Luna aren't *even* side characters.

    Rainbow Dash is a real character, and lots of people like her.

    Personally, I do like her personality. She's aggressive and brash, but the one time I feel she really went into unjustifiable "jerk" territory, it was because nobody stopped her. Usually she gets stopped. Her friends usually make it clear when she's going too far, and she does back off. Because she backs off, she's not *really* an asshole (which implies malicious intent), she's just unthinking and insecure.

    And because I like her personality, I like to ship her with the others. It helps that I like her interaction with the other ponies.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:39 No.24164836
    >>24164813
    Well I FUCKING DID
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:39 No.24164845
    >>24164754
    >>24164724
    Nobody else has posted in it yet though. That thread looks scary with all the hate on it's front door.
    >> (゚ 3゚)Onsokumaru !!f6Tejk6TlLT 03/09/11(Wed)23:40 No.24164859
    >>24164767
    There's a difference between dickweed and hot headed.
    She's just full of herself but thats the Rainbow Dash charm.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:40 No.24164871
    In that weed story, pinkie and dash offer twilight apple juice when she says it makes her throat hurt. You should NEVER drink something with sugar during smoking. NEVER.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:40 No.24164885
    >>24164836
    jesus, why don't you get yourself a tripcode if you wanna be such a fucking attention whore?
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:41 No.24164901
    >>24164824
    Well great news Fistful! I fucking hate Luna, Derpy, and Trixie to. Actually I only hate the fan interpretations. The characters in the show are fine.

    But you like Rainbow Dash's personality? Ugh. People shit all over Gilda then tell me how much they love Rainbow Dash. I don't understand.
    >> Tanner !ebRxo1tmWU 03/09/11(Wed)23:41 No.24164920
    >>24164871

    Why? i've had Pepsi and such while smoking and ive never had a problem
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:42 No.24164925
    >>24164885
    Well I FUCKING MIGHT
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:42 No.24164939
    >>24164767
    Well here's my reasoning.
    I like arrogant characters, they're memorial.
    Who did you remember from DBZ? (implying that you watched it)
    That one side character that apparently has Spike's voice actress?
    Or Vegeta? Of course Vegeta.
    He was the shits (in my opinion) and hotheaded as fuck. And badass (again in my opinion). She also has redeeming qualities unlike Vegeta.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:43 No.24164956
    >>24164920
    Your mouth gets dry and sticky as fuck. Perhaps it's just me?
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:43 No.24164969
    >>24164871
    lolwut
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:43 No.24164973
    Great

    Two MLP threads on the front page because some fucking idiot attention whore had to start another one

    FUCK OFF
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:44 No.24164987
    >>24164956
    I think it's you bro. I drink whatever the hell I want when I'm smoking.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:44 No.24165002
    >>24164956

    Everypony is different
    >> Malls Vasew !ZOcaX8ae32 03/09/11(Wed)23:44 No.24165003
    >>24164901
    Because RD found out about Gilda being a huge bitch and didn't take too kindly to that.

    Also Sonic Rainboom.
    >> (゚ 3゚)Onsokumaru !!f6Tejk6TlLT 03/09/11(Wed)23:45 No.24165011
    >>24164956
    I guess everyone is different.
    I remember drinking sprite and it felt gooood.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:45 No.24165035
    >>24164901
    I like every one
    >>24164790
    >My threads
    I am not liking this guy
    He knew there was already another thread and he created one more.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:46 No.24165053
    Urrrgh, choose a thread people!

    I'm seeing almost equal activity in both threads!
    >>24164790
    >>24161324
    >General Image Holdar
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:46 No.24165055
    >>24165002
    >>24164987
    >>24165011
    Hmmm, perhaps I should look into this. QUICK, TO THE LABORATORY!
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:48 No.24165112
    General image holder:

    Please delete the gen image from here and put it in one of the new threads. Otherwise we're just going to have thread wars.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:48 No.24165114
    >>24165055
    I like you bro.

    I'm thinking I'm gonna start using a tripcode, as a matter of fact.
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:48 No.24165117
    alot, if not most, of my dislike of comes from how much people won't shut up about her
    and i'll admit this, i saw ticket master way later than most of the episodes, even COTC, and when i did, i saw her as a jackass. the rest of the cast did it too, but she was first and worst of the bunch.
    and Twilight must be an idiot if she thinks that someone's selfish dreams are in the same vain as earning money to fix their livelihood
    HOWEVER
    Sonic Rainboom did change some of my feeling out Dash
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:49 No.24165146
    >>24165112
    Alright, but I'm rolling a die...
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:49 No.24165151
    >>24165053

    Looks like >>24164790 is already degenerating into trolling/arguing because the OP is trying to tell people what to post.

    Put the gen image in the other one.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:49 No.24165157
    >>24165112
    This.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:49 No.24165159
    >>24165112

    which is really silly
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/09/11(Wed)23:49 No.24165164
    >>24164901

    As I explained, Rainbow Dash isn't actively malicious. She basically acts like a jerk on accident. She says things without thinking, doesn't seem to have a good grasp of tact, and is insecure and tries to compensate for it by being very self-appreciating. But in the end she does value her friends, wants to be helpful, and cares for people.

    Gilda has none of those reasons going for her. She wasn't misunderstood, she didn't have any good motivation for acting the way she did, she seriously just thought everybody around her was beneath her and worth nothing but her contempt.

    This explains the difference in viewpoint between the two, at least mine anyway.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:50 No.24165175
    >>24165151
    >>24165151
    >>24165151
    >>24165151
    >>24165151
    >>24165151
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:50 No.24165176
    >>24165117
    I'm a hipster. Whenever someone asks for requests, I usually /r/ something about AJ because I don't see enough about her that isn't ApplexMac.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:50 No.24165187
    >>24165114
    *brohoof
    Also, you don't need a trip, just aquire a silly name, like me!
    >> Sergeant Sprinkles: World's Greatest Party Clown !!1Ci4x9DcklX 03/09/11(Wed)23:51 No.24165237
    >>24164939
    uh, I remember the Japanese Clark Kent
    Goku was my favorite hero
    And Buu was my favorite villain
    >> nameless 03/09/11(Wed)23:52 No.24165269
    >>24165187
    What should I call myself? (Using this as a place keeper so you know who I am)
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:52 No.24165282
    >>24165117
    Hmm...Interesting...Interesting.... It appears you have deviated from my previous calculations....Screen capping for future examination.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:53 No.24165322
    >>24165164
    So you go so far as to come up with this pretty nice background explanation for why Rainbow acts as she does, but when you go to counter my Gilda argument.

    You just say "Oh Gilda was just a jerk like on the show!"

    The fandom has made Dash their own character, like Trixie, Luna, and Derpy.

    Another reason I hate her.

    Also look at the 3 reasons given to me for why she is a good character.

    >>24164815
    >>24164659
    >>24164541
    Have I given a good enough reason yet? What more do you want Fistful?
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:54 No.24165342
    >>24165269
    http://dagobah.net/flash/know_your_destiny.swf
    Use this. It worked for me, the snuggie part came because I'm always at my desk in my snuggie
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:55 No.24165358
    >>24165322
    you know, people can like what they like and dislike what they dislike.
    >> Anonymous 03/09/11(Wed)23:56 No.24165411
    >>24165322
    >So you go so far as to come up with this pretty nice background explanation

    Sounds pretty accurate to the character as presented on the show.
    >> Father Killer, The Brutal Basement Dweller !!fFnHwjFV49q 03/09/11(Wed)23:57 No.24165438
    >>24165342
    Sweet. I am now Father Killer The brutal basement dweller.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/09/11(Wed)23:59 No.24165487
    >>24165438
    There ya go!
    >> Cottonmouth 03/09/11(Wed)23:59 No.24165490
    >>24165358
    Exactly.

    Fistful asked me why I disliked Rainbow Dash, so I explained. Glad you understand.

    >>24165411
    From my eyes it's not. That sounds like a fan explanation to me, giving her sympathy where she has none.
    >> Father Killer, The Brutal Basement Dweller !!fFnHwjFV49q 03/10/11(Thu)00:00 No.24165507
    >>24165487
    *brohoof*
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)00:04 No.24165610
    >>24165322

    Do you really believe that?

    What evidence can you bring forth that suggests Gilda's actions should NOT be taken at face-value? Almost certainly you could bring up nothing, because there is nothing to bring up. Gilda was a one-shot villain character. It is POSSIBLE, that she had good reasons to behave how she did, but in the show, we are not shown these things.

    We ARE shown things about Dash. Everything I said about her can be backed up by evidence in the show. Do you really want me to go through all the evidence we have for this?

    It's not like I'm pulling this out of my ass, it's how Dash is shown to be.

    And I don't care about what some random people like about Dash, as far as this discussion goes. Everybody has their reasons. I'm telling you mine.

    What I do want, if you were to press me, is for you to accept there are justifiable reasons to like Rainbow Dash. Some people have these reasons. I feel I have these reasons. I don't want you thinking I like Dash just because.
    >> Nopony Important 03/10/11(Thu)00:04 No.24165613
    >>24165342
    Tried that just for shits and giggles:

    Samuel L. McMuff, The Feared King Destined To Slay 4Chan.

    Well, fuck.
    >> Father Killer, The Brutal Basement Dweller !!fFnHwjFV49q 03/10/11(Thu)00:05 No.24165641
    >>24165613
    I just kept doing it until it was something cool.
    >> /co/mmander jesus, keeper of the snuggie 03/10/11(Thu)00:07 No.24165683
    >>24165613
    The one that gave me my name was commander jesus, the unstoppable super robot, destined to do nothing about niggers
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)00:08 No.24165721
    I've written pages upon pages in these threads on why I love Rainbow and why she's the most deep, interesting and dynamic character in the show. Probably enough to fill an entry for a scholastic journal. For the record it's way more than just because she's "a hawt lesbo", that was a joke answer, because basically Dash has a lot of haters and it's just not worth arguing with them at length anymore. We're over halfway through the season so you're a bit late to the party for things like long-winded character debates.
    >> Father Killer, The Brutal Basement Dweller !!fFnHwjFV49q 03/10/11(Thu)00:08 No.24165722
    >>24165683
    I was destined to liberate all cakes.

    Aww yeeeee
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)00:18 No.24165946
    >>24165610
    There are justifiable reasons to like Rainbow Dash.

    If you are talking about the 4chan version.

    But it's obvious we are going nowhere, and I need to finish this project instead of arguing with you here, and I'm sure you have better stuff to do as well.

    Like your fics though Fistful. I'll be watching for them.

    As long as their not RD shipping fics of course.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)00:30 No.24166228
    >>24165946

    You know I am not talking about "the 4chan version."

    I'm sorry Cottonmouth, but I think you're being outright unfair to me and my position. Which is, you know, disrespectful.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)00:31 No.24166266
    >>24166228
    you just noticed it?
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)00:34 No.24166338
    >>24166266

    I like to assume that people who disagree with me have legitimate viewpoints and are seriously interested in finding the truth of the matter.

    I don't like to assume it incorrectly, but it happens more often than I'd like.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)00:35 No.24166351
    >>24166338
    You are a good person
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)00:39 No.24166450
    >>24166228
    How. Fine. I didn't want to have to do this.

    Ticket Master ----> Wants the Ticket to crash her idol's performance over Applejack's completely legit reasons. At the very end selfishly calls the ticket for herself, only deciding to stop after being stared down.

    Boast Busters -----> "Wow she is so showing off!"
    "Here, let me show off."

    Dragonshy ----> Don't need to say

    Fall Weather Friends ----> Cheating, calling Twilight an egghead.

    Some of those are really condensed, such as Dragonshy and Fall Weather Friends.

    Sonic Rainboom was really her Boast Busters/Dragonshy/Suited for Success, and it drove the fandom to insanity with happiness.

    I'm sorry if it seems I offend you, but the Rainbow Dash discussed in these forums is NOT the one in the show. At least.. that's what I believe.

    If you ever want to talk to me I usually sit around in my fics. I would love for you to explain to me why I'm wrong and not spam up these threads. But that might be a bit awkward for you.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)00:41 No.24166489
    >>24166338
    Oh I'm interested believe me.

    Interested in why so many people are morphing this mean-spirited character on the show into their own Lesbo cuddly shipping machine.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)00:41 No.24166513
    >>24166450
    >I'm sorry if it seems I offend you, but the Rainbow Dash discussed in these forums is NOT the one in the show. At least.. that's what I believe.

    Everyone knows she's a bitch

    but she's still awesome
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)00:44 No.24166580
    >24166324
    Do you see this post over on the current general?

    That's what I'm talking about.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)00:45 No.24166596
    >>24166580
    And excuse me for being a complete newfag.

    I don't really post that often.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)00:58 No.24166926
    >>24161714

    Oh dear, this was beautiful. This needs a lot more recognition, if people don't mind my saying so. Do you have anything else that we can listen to?
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)01:07 No.24167104
    >Rainbow Dash is a bitch because she says what everyone is certainly thinking

    Cool story, guys. Rainbow Dash doesn't give a fuck what you think she's gonna call a coward a coward.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)01:17 No.24167325
    Does it bother anyone else the way the ponies bow to Celestia?

    I realize she's a princess, and you're supposed to bow to royalty, but well I guess this is just me thinking like an American, I can't help but think, "why are you bowing to her? She's not better than you just because she has wings and a horn."
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)01:20 No.24167411
    >>24166450

    I had to cut my reply in half:

    In The Ticket Master, while I can (and do) personally think that interrupting a show to show off is bad, it's still understandable. Rainbow Dash wants to be seen being amazing by the Wonderbolts. Obviously they'll be at their own show, so during their show is a good place to "show them her stuff." It's not just a little thing either, joining the wonderbolts is her entire life goal. Her entire reason for living is to become a member of the wonderbolts.

    It actually means that RD's reason to want the ticket is one of the better reasons to go, as a chance to make her dream come true is a far more noble goal than just going to a good party (Pinkie Pie), or seeing fancy flowers and critters (Fluttershy). It's even better than Rarity's reason, even if we do assume that "He" exists, because Rarity's dream is not to marry "Him" but to design outfits for Celestia.

    Applejack is the *only* pony who had an equally good, if not outright better reason for going than Rainbow Dash.

    And at the end when she had to be stared down, that's Rainbow Dash just not thinking. The very fact that she did not argue the point after being stared down shows that she realised after being nudged that she shouldn't have done what she did, and only did it due to unthinking excitement. She really did think she "got the ticket" for a moment.

    In Boast Busters, Rainbow Dash was not the first one to be annoyed by Trixie's boasting. Her first interaction with Trixie was also only to question why she thought she was so great, to which Trixie then made up her story about the Ursa Major. THEN Trixie actually issues a challenge to all the other ponies, and even then Rainbow Dash is not the first person to take up the challenge.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)01:22 No.24167455
    >>24167411

    In Dragonshy...quite frankly, Rainbow Dash was completely justified. "I was afraid to tell you I was afraid of dragons" is not a good reason to follow your friends up a mountain to save your town and hinder them the entire way. Rainbow Dash started off just recommending they not take Fluttershy, but Twilight insisted, and Fluttershy did not speak up to explain she didn't want to go. It wasn't until Fluttershy started to actually hinder their progress that Rainbow Dash became frustrated. And frustration is an appropriate response in that situation. Things might be different if Fluttershy had spoken up about not wanting to go, but that's not how it was.

    Fall Weather Friends is where we learn that Rainbow Dash has problems with insecurity. She is visibly sweating in nervousness when she thinks she's not going to perform well during that barrel run, and she continues to freak out when it becomes clear she's going to lose, and it's this insecurity that causes her to cheat. Keep in mind this is the only time I don't feel she's justified, and would agree she was being a dick. Insecurity is a character flaw, it doesn't justify cheating. As to the "Egghead" comment, it seemed to be playful ribbing. I say this because Applejack laughed too, Twilight did not get offended, and Rainbow Dash stopped after the joke was over.

    Sonic Rainboom for Rainbow Dash was just Fall Weather Friends, except instead of cheating, Rainbow Dash's insecurity caused crippling paralysis, and we focused on Rarity's personality in a negative light.
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)01:30 No.24167628
    >>24167411
    >>24167455
    You really thought these out huh?

    I don't agree with you on Ticket Master. Going to the gala with the intent on disrupting a performance is a stupid and selfish idea.

    Boast Busters you swayed me. She never really complained about Trixie's boasting, that was Twilight/Rarity/Applejack

    Dragonshy I actually agree. I ran through it real quick and cannot believe how much I forgot how annoying Fluttershy was. In fact, Applejack was a little TOO nice in this episode.

    Fall Weather Friends you agree with me, but you do bring up the insecurity. Still, I don't really see the insecurity as the competition goes on.

    I agree with Sonic Rainboom. Like I said, it was THE "Rainbow Dash" episode, portraying her in a positive light.

    Over all I think I'll lean towards you a bit. The show Rainbow Dash is still a bit of a jerk IMO, but I don't think I HATE her. She's just not anywhere near the top of the list for me.

    The way she is portrayed in the fandom is completely wrong though and makes me leave almost every single Rainbow shipping fic.
    >> Gilda's Fury !kmfdmRX7.c 03/10/11(Thu)01:35 No.24167718
    >>24167455 (on cheating)
    Applejack never told her she couldn't use her wings until after the contests were all over, which is a pretty big blow to AJ's argument. Notice how it's only "cheating" because she lost?
    >> Anonymous 03/10/11(Thu)01:36 No.24167736
    >>24167628 it was THE "Rainbow Dash" episode, portraying her in a positive light.
    PATHETIC FLUTTERSHY, PATHETIC

    YOU HAVE TO SAY "YAY" MORE LOUDLY
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)01:41 No.24167822
    >>24167718
    I don't really like that argument. It should be obvious to not use your wings really. I mean flying on a long-jump contest and a tug-of-war? Really?

    >>24167736
    That's kind of a good point, but she kind of reveals that she LIVES off of her friend's cheers, and at that moment she believes Fluttershy is the only one going.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)01:45 No.24167884
    Also Fistful, you said earlier Rainbow x Applejack was best ship.

    I thought you liked Applemac? I always thought that was unique about you.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)01:45 No.24167895
    >>24167628

    Well I did say that interrupting the performance was a bad idea. But the overall reason to go, "a chance to audition for the wonderbolts" is one of the better reasons. I really think Rainbow Dash just wasn't thinking it through, and strangely, nobody pointed it out to her that interrupting the show wasn't a good idea. I think if somebody did, she'd probably agree.

    The insecurity is the driving force for Rainbow Dash's cheating the entire time. We see she starts cheating because she's afraid of losing. She continues to be afraid of losing, and so continues to cheat. In fact, in the iron pony competition, her cheating seems to almost be reflexive, as a couple of times it was directly before she was going to lose that she suddenly panicked and cheated. This is most obvious during the long jump.

    My interpretation of the episode as a whole is that the the through the entire thing RD really did think, deep down, that Applejack was a better athlete, and couldn't deal with that. Her fear of messing up, of losing, kept her cheating.

    Like I said though, it's not a justification and it's the only time she's being what I would call a jerk.

    Nevertheless I maintain she is not overall a bitch, it all just comes down to her being unthinking and insecure. They're character flaws for an overall well-meaning and good natured pony, not the traits of an actively hostile one.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)01:49 No.24167959
    >>24167895
    I think this is where we come to our final compromise then.

    Everyone has different favorites right?

    Thanks for the discussion. I have to get to work on this stuff. thank you for your time and please get to writing something new eh? I quite liked "Normal". Keep up the good work and good luck.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)01:50 No.24167970
    >>24167884

    It was a turn of phrase.>>24167736


    I said later that Applemac was my favourite ship, but in that instance I was requesting Appledash. I don't want to be that guy who's always requesting the same thing, I like to mix it up, at least a little bit.

    >>24167736

    She was not being hostile to Fluttershy, she was giving a frank opinion. She doesn't seem to be very good at being tactful, because she does that a lot. Probably goes back to that "unthinking" thing.

    Of course Cottonmouth makes a good point too. It's very important to Rainbow Dash that Fluttershy cheer for her well. Rainbow Dash is too insecure to get along by herself.
    >> A Fistful of Apples !94yMGn.GiE 03/10/11(Thu)01:56 No.24168077
    >>24167959

    Like I said Cottonmouth, I mainly wanted you to accept that there are justifiable reasons to like canon Rainbow Dash. I do not believe I like Rainbow Dash due to some non-existing personality traits. I like her because how she is shown to be in the show.
    >> Cottonmouth 03/10/11(Thu)01:58 No.24168102
    >>24168077
    It's justifiable.

    adieu.

    If I spelt that right.



    [Return]
    Delete Post [File Only]
    Password
    Style [Yotsuba | Yotsuba B | Futaba | Burichan]